CHAPTER VII.
PENINSULAR CAMPAIGN-NEW MARKET CROSS ROADS.
246
Designs of the enemy--Trent's
farm-Movement to Savage station--Army trains--The reserve artillery; its value to the
army ;entrusted to McCalls division--Arrival of McCall at Savage station--Interview
with McClellan--Proposition to destroy the trains--The Hero of Mechanicsville prefers to
fight--Spirit of the troops--Scenes at Savage station--sorrowful partings--Rev. Junius
Marks--Distress of the wounded--Battle of Allen's farm--Gallantry of the Fifty-third
Pennsylvania regiment--Battle of Savage station--March to New Market road--A restless
night--Battle of New Market cross roads*--Treachery of a negro guide --The brunt of the
attack sustained by the Reserves--The Third regiment begins the battle--Charge of the
Seventh--Confusion on the left--Charge of the First brigade--Death of Colonel
Simmons--Cooper's and Kern's batteries--Capture and re-capture of Cooper's
battery--Charge of the Irish Brigade--Terrible struggle for Randall's battery--General
Meade wounded--General McCall captured--Colonel Roberts in command--Return of General
Seymour--Artillery abandoned by the army--Colonel Simmons--Captain Biddle--False
reports--Honor of the Reserves vindicated.
Two sanguinary battles had been
fought, in which the Confederate general had thrown his whole force against the right wing
of McClellan's army, in desperate efforts to crush it. After two days of battle, the Army
of the Potomac was concentrated on the south. bank of the Chickahominy, and the enemy had
gained no decided advantage. General Lee believed that the army was fleeing in frantic
disorder to its base of supplies at White
_________________________________________________________________________________________________
* This
battle has been variously designated as the battle of " Charles City
crossroads,"" Glendale" and" Nelson's farm." General Me Call,
whose division fought the battle, is, by military usage, the proper officer to name the
battle. He names it, in his report, the II Battle of New Market cross roads." This
designation has therefore been adopted by the author.
247
House, or
down the Peninsula towards Yorktown. Having failed to overwhelm and capture the troops on
the north bank of the river, he pushed his army down the roads between the Pamunkey and
the Chickahominy, expecting thus to intercept McClellan's retreat. The shattered divisions
of the right wing of the National army withdrew from the terrible field at Gaines' mill,
during the night of the 27th of June, and on Saturday morning, the 28th, reformed their
broken ranks on Trent's farm, on the bank of the river opposite the battle-field. General
McClellan had removed his headquarters from Dr. Trent's house to Savage station. The
immense trains, numbering over five thousand wagons, the seige train, a herd of
twenty-five hundred cattle, and all the materiel of the army were put in motion towards
Savage station. The powerful corps of reserve artillery, comprising eighteen splendid
batteries of, one hundred guns of the most approved pattern, the choice in finish and
equipment in the United States army, was still at Trent's farm. This park of artillery,
commanded by General Hunt, was the most valuable property on the Peninsula; without it the
army of the Potomac would be helpless; with it, posted in position like that at Malvern
Hill, the retreating army could bid defiance to the whole armed force of the Confederacy.
General McClellan did not undervalue this arm of his command; he knew that upon its safe
transfer to the James river, depended the safety of his army. There was but one narrow
road, leading through a deep swamp, available for the passage of trains and troops from
Savage station to Malvern Hill. Through this swamp, over a single road, the army was
pouring day and night. Baggage trains, supply trains, even siege trains might be destroyed
in an emergency, to keep them from the hands of the enemy, but the reserve artillery must
be guarded beyond peradventure, and placed in position south of White Oak swamp. General
McClellan nervously, and in deep anxiety, called to mind his ablest generals and his
trustiest troops. General McCall and his division of Pennsylvania
248
Reserves had
been intrusted with the defence of the right wing at Mechanicsville; they had fully
justified the confidence reposed in them by the commanding general. At Gaines' Mill,
too, they had put to shame the regulars, and paid a terrible price in blood for their
valor. There were other divisions which had rested while the Reserves had been fighting
and marching, without sleep and without rations. But McClellan would take no risks in a
labor so momentous. General McCall was therefore ordered to guard Hunt's artillery and
conduct it in safety from Trent's farm to the Quaker road south of White Oak swamp.
The guns, caissons, forges, battery
wagons and ammunition trains, numbered about three hundred vehicles, and when added to
McCall's artillery and transportation, made a train seven miles in length. General McCall
accepted the post of honor and of responsibility, with a full comprehension of the arduous
duties it imposed on his men. The brigade commanders were ordered to distribute the
regiments throughout the train at proportionate intervals, and to keep flanking parties
out to the right and left. The night of the 28th was dark and rainy. At nine o'clock
McCall's division, having in charge the artillery, stretched out in the road from Trent's
farm towards Savage station; the road was narrow; other divisions and trains were moving
over other roads, and some were following McCall's train. Near the middle of the night, an
officer rode up to General McCall in the thick darkness, and informed him that he was on
the wrong road, and that his train must be turned back. The general replied, he was on the
right road, and would continue forward. An hour later the officer again appeared on the
road, and informed General McCall that it was the order of General McClellan that he
should countermarch his division to another road and allow another command to pass
over the road he was then on. General McCall replied to the officer: "Give General
McClellan my compliments, and say to him, that General McCall says, the road he is on is
narrow, the night is very dark, his
249
train is
long and heavy, and that it is impracticable to reverse his march; moreover, the men are
much fatigued from excessive duties, and must not be subjected to unnecessary hardships.
He must, therefore, be permitted to move forward on this road." No further orders
were received by General McCall, and the division spared the confusion and toil of a
countermarch of six miles in mud and darkness, advanced on the direct road to Savage
station. At one o'clock on Sunday morning, General McCall arrived at McClellan's
headquarters at Savage station. He found the commanding general surrounded by his corps
and some of his division commanders, standing around a fire, discussing the situation of
the army. When General McCall arrived, General McClellan stepped forward and said:
"Here is General McCall, the hero of Mechanicsville." General McCall bowed, and,
without further ceremony, informed McClellan of the order received to move on another
road, and repeated his reasons for continuing his march. General McClellan approved his
course, and leading him aside, said in a low tone of voice: "General McCall, it is my
desire to reach the James river before I am attacked by the enemy; if I destroy all the
trains including the private baggage, we can reach James river in twenty-four hours; but
if I attempt to take the trains with me, it will take us forty-eight hours to gain the
river. What do you advise me to do?" Now, it must be remembered, that 'McCall's
division had done more fighting, and had been subjected to greater hardships during the
three days that had just passed, than any other troops in the army; also, that at that
very hour of rain and darkness, his gallant Reserves were toiling through the mud guarding
a numerous train of artillery; that General McCall, like his troops, had been three days
and three nights without rest or sleep, and almost without food. All this the
major-general commanding well knew, and knowing, perhaps, expected General McCall would
gladly clear the road for his artillery by destroying the trains in his front. But never
was man more mistaken.
250
Shaking the
rain from his water-proof coat, and removing his cap from his head, General McCall stood
erect, and looking down on McClellan's half upturned face, said " General McClellan,
I don't know that I sufficiently understand the situation of the army to advise you; but
from what I do know, I would fight over every inch of the ground from here to the James,
before I would destroy a wagon. The moment you destroy your trains, you demoralize the
army." To these heroic words McClellan made no reply, but the two generals in silence
returned to the company around the fire. Greater compliments could not have been paid to
men in arms than were that night awarded to the Pennsylvania Reserves. The Major-general
commanding had entrusted to them the casket of his army, indeed, of the nation; the
general commanding the division reposed such high confidence in his troops, that he was
bold, without hesitation, to deliver a reply to General McClellan, regarding the
destruction of the trains, that in itself did much towards saving the Army of the Potomac.
He believed his men were able to march to the James with their baggage, and if necessary,
fight the enemy at every step. Meanwhile the troops toiled through the deep forests, in
darkness and rain, marching by the side of the artillery, resolved to defend it against
the, enemy, or to die in the road. On Sunday morning, wet and covered with mud, hungry,
and exhausted by the terrible night march, the men reached Savage station.
Here everything was in disorder; the
fields were crowded with trains, the woods filled with wounded men. Since Friday evening,
all had been hurry and confusion. The hurrying to and fro of officers in hot haste,
carrying, and coming for orders to and from every part of the army; the arrival of the
long trains of ambulances filled with wounded soldiers, and the almost endless line of
stretcher-bearers with their wounded companions on their shoulders, poured in continuous
streams into the open space about the station. The grounds around the houses, the floors
of the barns,
251
stables, and
out-houses were covered with vast multitudes of bleeding, groaning, and dying men. The
uncertainty with regard to future movements, the hurling together of the immense trains of
the army of the Potomac, and the rumor that Jackson was marching against the
communications of the army with the White House, added to the confusion and
consternation that already palsied the stoutest heart. The railroad trains had been
employed to the last moment to carry the wounded to White House. At ten o'clock on
Saturday morning, the 28th of June, the telegraph wires connecting Savage station with
White House, suddenly ceased working, and it was evident the enemy had possession of the
railroad. A train of cars filled with five hundred wounded men was at the station ready to
move, when the telegraph operator announced that his communication was cut. The train
moved cautiously down the road three or four miles, to learn if possible the condition of
things towards White House; it soon returned to the station, and all were satisfied that
the forces of the enemy had reached the railroad. The poor broken and wounded men, whose
brave hearts had borne them up to endure all hardships, still waited on the cars, hoping
against hope, and rejected the offers of their friends to remove them to beds on the
ground. Between two and three thousand sick and wounded were in the houses and tents, and
under the trees at Savage station. Deep gloom and sore distress fell upon all; there were
a thousand rumors of things most improbable, but the despondency of the men prepared
them to believe the most extravagant stories, and the confusion that surrounded them
increased their consternation.
When, therefore, on Sunday morning,
the Reserves halted at the station, the men left the ranks, and amid the army of wounded,
sought out their companions, and administered for their wants; for such as could walk they
made canes and crutches; they bound up the wounds of some, and aided many to follow their
regiments in the retreat across the swamp ; to others who could not follow them, they gave
252
water, and
rations of bread, meat, sugar and coffee, and each noble patriot, placed in the pocket of
his wounded companion all the money he had in his possession. The parting of brave men,
companions in arms, is rarely witnessed under more distressing circumstances. The
strongest heart was melted in sorrow; many a manly cheek was wet with tears as the
soldiers bade farewell to each other, expecting never to meet again. Fathers dragged
themselves away from the couches of their sons, son forsook father, and brother parted
from brother. Both were patriotic and brave; one, well, robust and strong; the other,
all bleeding, maimed and dying. They parted like brave men. Those who went, to die
gloriously in battle, or, to survive with the vindicated honor of their country; those who
remained, doomed to the most terrible hardships that befall men, who in war become the
prisoners of a vengeful foe. Without physician, nurse or attendant, many, died beneath the
trees where their companions had left them; others, carried towards Richmond, either
died on the way and were buried in the swamps, or taken to the Confederate prisons, died
of neglect, filth, and abuse.
Reverend Junius J. Marks, D. D.,
chaplain of the Sixty-third regiment of Pennsylvania volunteers, one of the most
faithful christian ministers in this country, remained at Savage station to take charge of
the wounded. This noble follower of his Divine Teacher, ,had for many clays and nights of
watchfulness and toil, labored for the alleviation of the pains and hardships of the
disabled patriots on the Peninsula, and now, in the hour of severest trial and greatest
need, he would not forsake them. When it was apparent that the wounded would be left
behind, Doctor Marks, feeling that he was subject to the orders of Colonel Hays,
commanding the Sixty-third regiment, or of General Kearney in whose command the regiment
was brigaded, and knowing that these officers had already marched away towards James
river, called on General Heintzelman and stated to him the situation of the wounded at the
station, and asked
253
the general,
what, under the circumstances, he would advise him to do. General Heintzelman replied:
"I cannot advise you. If you remain, you will become a prisoner, no man can tell you
what you may have to endure; you will lose all. You have no commands holding you here, and
if you please to go with the army, no one ought to blame you."
Doctor Marks had hoped that General
Heintzelman would order him to remain, for, feeling that to leave the men who were then
under his charge, would be both dishonorable and cruel, he had determined to stay with
them, live or die ; lie wished however to be defended in his conduct by the order or
advice of a general officer. He nevertheless remained with his sick and wounded
countrymen, and on the 30th of June, became a prisoner of war.
At three o'clock on Sunday afternoon,
General Heintzelman and staff' mounted their horses and galloped away from the station. Up
to that time the disabled soldiers had not known that they were to be left behind to fall
into the hands of the enemy. Doctor Marks says: " When it became manifest that such
was to be their fate, the scenes of distress could not be pictured by human language. Some
of the wounded men, who were left in their tents, struggled forth through the grounds,
exclaiming, they `would rather die than fall into the hands of the rebels; I heard
one man cry out 0 my God! is this the reward I deserve for all the sacrifices I
have made, the battles I have fought, and the agony I have endured from my wounds.
Some of the younger soldiers wept like children; others turned pale, and some fainted.
Poor fellows ! they thought this was the last drop in the cup of bitterness, but there
were yet many to be added."
After having made a short halt, the
Reserves moved on from Savage station, and early in the afternoon crossed White Oak swamp
creek. General McCall had received orders to park the artillery train on the first firm
ground south of the swamp, and to place his troops in a position to repel an attack from
the direction of Richmond. The division remained in line of battle on the border of the
254
swamp until
five o'clock in the afternoon. It was then relieved of the charge of the artillery, which
was out of danger, and was ordered to move forward on the road leading to Turkey Island
bend on the James river.
General Porter, to whose corps the
Reserves were attached, had orders to move forward. with his command on the Quaker road to
the James. When the head of the column reached the New Market road, it turned to the
right, and marched westward towards Richmond. The guide, having inquired of the
inhabitants for the Quaker road, was informed that it entered the New Market road about
five miles westward from the intersection of the White Oak swamp road. At the point
indicated by the citizens, there is an old abandoned road leading through the woods to the
river, which the inhabitants called the Quaker road, but on the military maps used by
General McClellan, this road was not laid down, but a road three miles further east was
designated as the Quaker road. When the command had followed for some distance, the
lead of the guide, accompanied by an officer on General Porter's staff; General Meade, who
was in the advance, insisted that they were on the wrong road, and that the Quaker road
had already been passed. He halted his brigade, and riding forward with the guide, turned
into the Old Quaker road, and discovered that it was overgrown, crossed by ditches and
fences, and was therefore impassable. It was now about midnight, and so dark that it was
impossible to make an examination of the country, General Meade reported the situation to
General McCall, who despatched a messenger to General Porter. General Porter rode forward,
and insisted that they were on the right road, but directed General McCall to encamp his
division by the side of the road until morning. The other divisions of Porter's Corps,
Sykes' and Morrell's, continued forward on the road, and after a fruitless attempt to
enter the Old Quaker road, countermarched, and moving back marched by McCall's camp,
reached the Quaker road of the military maps, by a private road through the woods, and
255
continued
his march to the river; he, however, neglected to withdraw the Reserves, or to send
General McCall any orders as to the disposition of his division. General Porter has since
explained his conduct by saying that, " he no longer considered McCall's troops as
attached to his command." Yet no order had been issued detaching them from the
Fifth Corps. McCall and his gallant men; who had done more severe fighting, .tedious
marching and hard labor, since the morning of the 26th of June, than any, other troops in
the Army of the Potomac, were again, by the blunder of the commander of the Fifth Corps,
placed in the front, and indeed almost within the camps of the enemy.
While the advance guard was pushing
forward towards the James, the rear guard was holding the pursuing enemy at bay. During
the night of the 28th, Generals Sumner's and Heintzelman's corps, and Smith's division
were ordered to an interior line, the left resting on Keyes's old intrenchments, and
curving to the right, so as to cover Savage station. These troops were ordered to hold
this position until dark of the 29th, in order to cover the withdrawal of the trains, and
then to fall back across the swamp and unite with the remainder of the army.
General Sumner vacated his works at
Fair Oaks on the 29th of June, at daylight, and marched his command to Orchard station,
halting at Allen's farm, between Orchard and Savage station. The enemy who had been
greatly perplexed by the movement of the Army of the Potomac on Saturday, now discovered
that General McClellan had abandoned his base at the White House, and was moving towards
the James river. The rebel forces were immediately sent in pursuit of the retreating
army. When General Sumner and General Heintzelman discovered that the enemy was hanging
on their rear, they formed their corps in line of battle on Allen's farm, determined to
punish their pursuers, and at the same time ensure the safe withdrawal of the trains from
Savage station. General Heintzelman
256
formed his
corps south of the railroad, facing towards Richmond; Richardson's and Sedgwick's
divisions were formed on the right of the railroad, and General Slocum's division was sent
forward to Savage station.
At nine o'clock in the forenoon, the
rebels approached this line of battle, and immediately commenced a furious attack on the
right of Sedgwick's division, but were quickly repulsed. The enemy next attacked the left
of Richardson's division, making desperate efforts to carry a position held by Captain
Hazzard's battery and the Fifty-third Pennsylvania regiment, commanded by Colonel Brooks.
The valiant Pennsylvanians, however, had taken shelter behind a log house, and kept up a
steady fire on the advancing enemy, who three times charged the position, but were as
often repulsed, and finally compelled to retire in disorder. At the close of this
spirited engagement, called the battle of Allen's farm, General Heintzelman withdrew his
corps from the defensive works on the Williamsburg road, and crossed White Oak swamp at
Brackett's ford; General Sumner retired to Savage station. Opposite the station, between
the railroad and the Williamsburg road, is a large plain, comprising an area of several
hundred acres. The ground gradually ascends from the station towards the road. On this
plain General Sumner, who commanded the rear guard of the grand army, drew up his troops
in line of battle. Sumner had his own corps, Franklin's and part of Heintzelman's. Like a
great wall thrown across the path of a powerful army, these lines of armed men stood for
hours in the open field, many of them motionless as statues, waiting the approach of the
enemy. Long and numerous trains of artillery, wagons and funeral ambulances, on various
avenues, approached, and passing behind this living wall, poured in a continuous stream
through the narrow pass of White Oak swamp. The van guard had passed the swamp and risen
to a position on firm ground, flanked by the impassable morass, where part of the trains
could rest. General Keyes had already established commu-
257
nication
with the gunboats in the James, and General Porter's corps stretched from the swamp to
the right wing of Keyes' command. But the fate of the army was still in the hands of the
rear guard standing in battle array on the plain at Savage station. Never were soldiers
called to the discharge of more important duties! Never were troops snore prepared for the
sacrifice !
At five o'clock a great cloud of dust
was seen rising from the fields towards the Chickahominy. The enemy had rapidly
concentrated his forces on the south bank of the river, and was now marching to battle,
confident of victory and spoils. The veteran hero, commanding the rear guard of the
national army, sat calmly on his horse, and from the rising clouds of dust, ever varying,
ever increasing, keenly conjectured the numbers and the designs of the enemy. The
artillery was trained on the approaches through which the enemy would come. Orderlies,
aids de camp, and commanding officers were hurrying along the line from centre to right
and left; the men were in position, each with heroic resolution determined to resist the
enemy till victory or death closed the contest.
The rebels approached through a dense
woods which concealed their movements until they were within a short distance of the
National lines. They then emerged from their concealment, pushed forward their artillery
to commanding positions, and opened a furious fire of shot and shell. Sumner's batteries
replied vigorously, and the guns on both sides were handled with great skill. For an hour,
not a musket was fired. The lines of the army remained motionless, while the roar and
crash of artillery filled the air with hideous sounds, and shook the earth with its
fearful concussion. Suddenly a wild yell pierced the air; the whole mass of the enemy's
troops sprung forward from the forest, and rushed into the open field in front of the
National forces. Sheets of flame burst simultaneously from both lines, and the roar of
musketry vied with the thunder of artillery. The enemy was hurled back to the railroad,
but advanced again and
258
again to the
close contest, each time replacing with fresh troops their broken ranks. Sumner and his
troops well knew their situation. To retire was death; to stand firm could be no more. The
mortal combat raged with fearful carnage till dark. At one time the enemy had almost
succeeded in outflanking Sumner's position; a hostile brigade emerged from the woods and
rushed towards the rear of the left flank, but suddenly a battery opened on it with grape
and canister, tearing through its columns with such accurate range, that the enemy fled in
disorder, and relinquished his purpose. The pall of battle and the shades of night brought
no relief. The roar of cannon and the shriller sound of musketry were incessant. The
contending regiments, at times, stood face to face, and at the distance of only a few
yards delivered volley after volley into each other's ranks. The enemy in his most furious
efforts failed to overwhelm the rear guard, and drive its broken regiments into the swamp.
Sumner not only successfully resisted the attack, but had sent death in such terrible
measures through the enemy's masses, that, becoming confused, the rebel regiments
commenced firing on each other and were easily forced from the field.
When General McClellan, beyond the
White Oak swamp heard that Sumner had repulsed the enemy, he ordered him to retire across
the swamp. But the Old Hero had his blood up, and asked for reinforcements that he might
renew the battle in the morning. That, however, was contrary to the plans of the
commanding general, and "Bull Sumner was choked off." He therefore retired
during the night, and on Monday morning joined the right wing of the army south of the
swamp.
The killed and wounded in the battle
of Savage station, like those in the battles at Gaines' mill, and Allen's faun, were left
on the field, to receive the harshest treatment a bitter foe could inflict. Many of these
noble defenders of the Union died from neglect, others from abuse, and some, distressed
and broken in spirit, found a happy relief is death.
259
The lines of troops, and the immense
trains marched in a continuous column through the swamp, and over White Oak creek. The
roar of battle in the Tear urged them to a quicker pace; all day and all night long the
living stream rolled onward. By midnight all the troops were on the road, and at five
o'clock on Monday morning General French's brigade, which formed the rear guard to
Sumner's corps, crossed White Oak creek, and destroyed the bridge.
The labor of Monday, June 30, was the
safe transfer of the trains to the bank of the James, under the protection of the
gunboats. For this purpose the troops were placed in lines of battle on the roads leading
from Richmond down the Peninsula. Generals Keyes and Porter were in position at Turkey
bend on James river. General Franklin guarded the passes of White Oak swamp. Early in the
morning General Heintzelman destroyed the bridge at Bracketf s ford, and felled trees
across the Charles City road. He then withdrew his corps to the point where the New Market
road crosses the Charles City road. Kearny's division was formed in front of the Charles
City road with its left joining the right of McCall's division, which was formed across
the New Market road, facing towards Richmond ; Hooker's division as formed to the left and
rear of McCall's position. Part of Sumner's corps was with General Franklin at White Oak
swamp, and the remainder formed in the rear of Heintzelman's left.
The enemy had been so severely
punished by General Sumner at Savage station, that he was slow to pursue the retreating
rear guard. It was not until after twelve o'clock on the 30th of June, that he appeared
opposite Franklin's position on White Oak creek. The enemy pushed forward several pieces
of artillery, and opened a vigorous fire on the divisions of Smith and Richardson, and
Naglee's brigade, at White Oak swamp bridge. This artillery fire was continued
throughout the day. Richardson's division suffered severely; Captain Hazzard's battery,
after losing many connoniers, and Captain Hazzard being mortally
260
wounded; was
compelled to retire. It was replaced by ]Pettit's battery, which partially silenced the
enemy's guns.
General Franklin held his position
until after dark, repeatedly driving back the enemy in their attempts to cross the creek.
Finding it impossible to force the
passage of White Oak creek in the face of the rear-guard,. General Zee detached a powerful
force to cross further up the swamp, and ordered the general in command to seize the
intersection of the Charles City and New Market roads, and thus cut the line of retreat of
the army o£ the Potomac. The enemy had already occupied the New Market road, in front of
McCall's division, and waited for reinforcements before beginning an attack.
On the night of the 29th, General
McCall had thrown forward the First brigade, commanded by Colonel Simmons, as an out-post
to watch the movements of the enemy. The -night was intensely dark, so that the men were
unable to .distinguish objects a few feet from them. Advancing about a, mile from camp,
Colonel Simmons formed his troops on a private road at right angles with the New Market
road; he directed his men to lie down in order, by the roadside, -ready to spring into
line at a moment's notice. A line of pickets was formed fifty paces in front of the
brigade, and special countersigns were devised by which the pickets and the men from the
different regiments could recognize each other. During the night several alarms occurred.
At one time a number of battery horses broke loose, and rushed down the road with the
fierceness of a cavalry charge; after midnight brisk firing was heard in the rear, caused,
(as was afterwards learned) by a false alarm; again, a soldier sleeping a nervous,
restless sleep, holding his gun in his hands ready to meet the foe, dreamed that the enemy
was charging upon the brigade, and in a deep sepulchral voice, called out to his comrades,
" fall in ! fall in ! " Numerous dogs at the farm houses in the vicinity kept up
a continual barking, and thus not only aided to drive away sleep by their noise,
261
but also
apprised the officers and men of the approach of the enemy. The frequent alarms made sleep
impossible, and
the command
passed one of those nights of silent excitement, that preys so terribly on the energies of
the soldier, and more unnerves the body than the severest shock of battle.
On Monday morning the brigade was
withdrawn, and the division camped in an open field, where the men prepared breakfast from
the scanty remnants in their haversacks. Surrounding the field occupied by the Reserves,
was a plain densely covered with a forest of sedge pines; General McCall taking advantage
of the grounds skillfully posted his troops on both sides of the New Market road. He knew
full well, that by the neglect of his superior officers, his division had again been
placed at the point of greatest danger. He therefore formed his brigades in line of
battle, feeling that the fate of the army once more rested on the arms of the
Pennsylvania Reserves. Days of fierce battle, and nights of toilsome marches, had sadly
worn upon the strength of the regiments. Most of the men were fitter subjects for the
hospital than for
the
battle-field. Officers and men, however, felt that once more, tremendous efforts and
terrible sacrifices must be
made, to
save the army of the Potomac from destruction, and the National arms from disgrace. Worn
and weary, but
with
undaunted spirit the battle-scarred soldiers again stood in serried ranks; their faces
straight to the foe; the artillery with their pieces well to the front, and the infantry
grasping tightly their arms, each man resolved to resist till death, the rebel hordes that
were swarming in the forests before them.
General McCall had formed his line of
battle across the open plain; the Second brigade, commanded by General Meade, forming the
right wing, crossed the New Market road; the Third brigade, commanded by General Seymour,
was on the,
left, and extended to a marshy woods south of the field; the First brigade, commanded by
Colonel Simmons, was held in reserve, and was protected by a wooded hill in the rear of
the centre of the line. The grounds were
262
well chosen,
and made an advantageous battle-field, but the Reserve corps was too small to fully occupy
it. Its thinned ranks, and contracted lines no longer stretched in massive columns across
extensive fields, with unbroken front to the foe. Still, what was left of the noble corps,
a heroic band, formed in line, and occupied the ground. Randall's regular battery that
supplied the place of De Hart's, which had been demolished at Gaines' mill, was posted on
the 'right; Cooper's and Kern's took positions in the centre ; two New York German
batteries from Porter's corps, which had become detached from their division, were placed
in position on the left. Colonel Roberts With the First regiment, and Colonel Jackson with
the Ninth, were ordered to support the batteries in the centre. The Fourth regiment
Colonel Magilton, and the Seventh commanded by Colonel Harvey, were on the extreme Tight
with Randall's battery. The two remaining companies of the Eleventh regiment, commanded by
Captain Porter, were temporarily attached to the Seventh. The Tenth regiment commanded by
Colonel Kirk, and the Twelfth, Colonel Taggart, supported the German batteries on the
left.
When, on the morning of the 3oth of
June, General McCall received the order from General McClellan to form his division on the
New Market road, and to hold the enemy in check until the trains had passed the cross
roads in his rear, he supposed other divisions of the army would be formed on the right
and left of his position to protect his flanks. The general-in-chief, however, was not
present on the field, either to form the line or to superintend the battle, and the corps,
and divisions, being without a common leader, took positions, and fought independently.
The only instructions given from headquarters were, that the ` several commands should
resist the enemy, until the immense army, trains, moving towards the James had passed all
the cross roads, and arrived in camps on the bank of the river. Of these disjointed and
independent divisions, McCall held the centre, resting on the principal
263
road from
Richmond. The main body of the Confederate force advanced on this road, it being Lee's
object to break through the lines of the National army at New Market and Charles City
cross roads. Had he succeeded in this movement, he would have seized the only approaches
to the James river, would have divided. McClellan's army, and utterly destroyed the two
fragments in detail. From the disposition of General Lee's forces, it necessarily
followed, that the brunt of the attack would fall on McCall's position. General Lee had
sent forward his most powerful divisions with orders to seize the Quaker road. One of
these, commanded by General A. P. Hill, had assailed McCall's troops at Mechanicsville in
a battle, in which the Confederate generals acknowledged that "they were repulsed
at every point with unparalleled loss." Now, again, these same troops, reinforced by
Longstreet's division, making a force of nearly twenty thousand men, were to be hurled
against the remnant of the Reserves, numbering less than seven thousand effective
soldiers.
The sound of artillery had been heard
from nine o'clock in the morning, pounding incessantly, far away towards White Oak swamp;
gradually it drew nearer convincing the soldiers, that the tide of battle was rolling
towards the centre. General McCall, believing that the enemy would approach his position
by moving down the New Market road, had thrown forward a squadron of the Fourth
Pennsylvania cavalry to serve as pickets and videttes ; and when the enemy drew nearer,
lie sent forward the First regiment commanded by Colonel Roberts, and the Third commanded
by Colonel Sickel to support the cavalry. As Colonel Roberts was about moving out with his
regiment, a negro guide was sent to him who professed to be familiar with the country.
After following the colored man for some distance, Colonel Roberts ordered
Lieutenant-Colonel McIntire to station the companies, and form the line of pickets. The
regiment marched on over a by-road through the thickets, and the companies, one after the
other, were dropped from
264
the column
and expanded into picket lines; just as the last company had reached its destination,
Colonel Roberts discovered that the guide had acted falsely, and had led the regiment
into the lines of the enemy. The company imme. diately countermarched at double-quick
along the line, and gathering up the several companies, the regiment reformed and withdrew
to the New Market road just in time to escape capture.
Before three o'clock on Monday
afternoon, the enemy appeared in force in front of the deployed lines of the First and
Third regiments. Colonel Roberts made several efforts to draw the enemy from the woods,
and to open the engagement, the rebels, however, obstinately refused to advance, but
kept up an irregular fire from their concealed position. General Meade, hearing the firing
in his front, rode forward to ascertain its nature and cause. Having reached the
position occupied by the First regiment, he inquired of Colonel Roberts, why he did not
engage the enemy, and ascertain his strength. Colonel Roberts replied he had sent out his
skirmishers to draw the rebels from the woods, but they refused to accept battle; that he
had himself, with a squad of cavalry, galloped along the front beyond his skirmish line,
and had drawn a brisk fire from the enemy in the wood, and had also seen that the woods
were occupied by a heavy force. About the same time sharp firing was heard on the left,
and it was evident that Colonel Sickel had encountered the enemy in force. Colonel
Roberts was then ordered to retire to the line of battle and resume his position in
support of Cooper's battery.
As soon as the rebel troops arrived
in front of Colonel Sickel, who was in the wood south of the New Market road, a skirmish
immediately commenced; the enemy at first made only a weak demonstration in front, to
attract the attention of the regiment, and at the same time pushed forward flanking
columns for the purpose of cutting off and capturing it. Colonel Sickel discovered the
manoeuvres of the enemy, and at once engaged his advancing columns.
265
A terrific
encounter ensued, during which the Third regiment repulsed the enemy, and then retired
in order on the line of battle in the field. The enemy now opened an artillery fire
along the entire front of McCall's line, and under cover of a shower of shot and shell,
sent forward a regiment against the right centre. The rebels came front the woods and
advanced boldly into the field, delivering their fire as they came; Colonel Harvey,
commanding the Seventh regiment, and two companies of the Eleventh, was ordered to meet
the hostile regiment with the bayonet. The men sprung from behind the battery, and darting
forward with the most reckless daring, drove the enemy from the field; to cover the return
of the regiment, Randall's battery opened with grape and canister, which unfortunately, to
a small extent, struck the men of the Seventh, and created temporary confusion, but the
men were too well drilled in battle to be thrown into disorder, and hence immediately
reformed in their original position behind the battery.
General McCall now discovered that
the enemy was about to make an effort to carry away his left wing; the general rode
forward with the Bucktails, and directed Major Stone to form his battalion in a narrow
slip of woods on the left, in front of the line. Almost immediately a heavy column of
rebel troops were discovered moving through the woods threatening the left flank. The New
York battery men, without attempting to train their guns on the advancing rebels fired a
few rounds high over their heads, and then cutting their harness, rushed to the rear with
the horses, breaking through and deranging the lines of infantry. The enemy talking
advantage of the temporary confusion, charged with hideous yells in overwhelming force
upon the broken lines. The Twelfth regiment, which had been divided by order of General
Seymour, and posted on the extreme left was crushed by the power of the enemy, and six
companies were cut off from the division and driven back towards the left and rear on
General Hooker's division. General McCall, with the true genius of a soldier, had
discovered the move-
266
ments, and
quickly understood the designs of the enemy he ordered the remaining regiments of the left
wing to change front, and sent forward the gallant Simmons with the Fifth regiment,
commanded by Lieutenant-colonel Fisher, and the Eighth, commanded by Colonel Hays, to
support Colonel Jackson and Colonel Kirk, of the Ninth and Tenth. Colonel Simmons faced
his regiments to the left, and ordered them to charge. The dense masses of the enemy were
rushing with screams and yells from the forest, and were dashing across the field,
confident of an easy victory; the more confident, because of the disorder on the extreme
left. The four regiments, led by Colonel Simmons, were formed in line to stem this tide
of death; to hurl back the exultant foe, to snatch victory from victorious arms, or, to be
crushed beneath the weight of overwhelming numbers, was the dread alternative to which
these patriot troops were called. No soldier on that field, in that awful moment, more
fully appreciated the duties and the terrors of the hour than did the heroic Simmons. He
was ordered to charge diagonally to the left. For an instant be turned his face back,
fixing his eyes upon the commanding general to reassure himself that he was right; then
again to the head of his column, his great heart swelling with patriotic devotion, the
voice of the soldier, in commanding tones, heard above the tumult of battle, rang out
clear and loud along the serried lines, "BRIGADE ! FORWARD !CHARGE !" With eyes
fixed on the enemy, and rifles firmly grasped, forward rushed the men to meet in a death
struggle the advancing foe. The full, round cheer of the patriots, rising high over their
ranks, drowned the screech and yell of the rebels; the thunder of artillery and roar of
musketry rose to their most furious might; bayonet clashed with bayonet in fearful thrust
and parry; the impetuosity of the charge brought both columns to a halt. Now was the
terrible moment, hanging in the balance, equipoised, was the fate of the day, the life
of the Reserve Corps, the existence of the army. FORWARD ! rang out from the head of the
267
column, and
rolled along the line in tones that at once struck terror to the hearts of the enemy, and
fired the patriot troops with victorious zeal. The rebel masses broken and confused were
pushed back to the forests. The left wing was saved; the power of the enemy was broken;
nearly three hundred rebel prisoners were sent to the rear; the day was half won. But the
noble Simmons fell mortally wounded. Multitudes of dead and wounded patriots covered the
field. The lines of the charging column, when it entered the woods, necessarily, became
broken. Unable to reform under the murderous fire from the enemy's artillery and
infantry, the regiments fell back to the woods behind their original position, where they
reformed the line behind the Second regiment and the Bucktails, and held their ground till
dark, when the enemy withdrew from the contest.
The Second regiment, commanded by
Colonel McCandless, had been ordered to follow the Bucktails to the extreme left, but
before they had reached their designated position, the four regiments that had so
gallantly repulsed the rebels were broken and driven back closely followed by the enemy.
The Second and the Bucktails immediately faced to the front, laid down and allowed the
retiring regiments to pass over them, and then springing to their feet, met the advancing
rebels with a fierce charge that checked their progress, and gave time for the other
regiments to form in the edge of the woods. Four companies of the Twelfth regiment also
formed in line and joined the Second. Six companies of the Twelfth had been cut off and
driven to the rear, where they were formed by Major Baldy, and subsequently under
command of Colonel Taggart, fought bravely by the side of a Massachusetts regiment in
Hooker's division.
When the German batterymen and the
detached companies of the Twelfth regiment, together with the squads in charge of the
prisoners, came upon General Hooker's lines, he supposed McCall's division had been
routed. A body
268
of rebel
troops that had pursued these detachments were vigorously attacked by General Hooker's
troops and rolled back on the centre of the Reserve Corps. The enemy then attacked with
great fury that portion of McCall's line, by charging with heavy columns on Cooper's and
Kern's batteries. Colonel Roberts, commanding the First regiment, had, with a counter
charge, met the enemy who was advancing against Cooper's battery, at the same instant that
Colonel Simmons had led the charge to the left. Three companies of Colonel Robert's
regiment under the immediate command of Major Todd, moved to the left oblique with the
Fifth regiment, and partook of the glory and death of that tremendous onslaught; the other
companies repulsed the enemy in front of the battery and then resumed their original
position. The enemy made a second attempt to capture the batteries, and Colonel Roberts
again, in a most desperate contest, drove him back into the woods. A third attempt to
drive the men from their guns, resulted only in repeated slaughter to the charging
columns. The batterymen had passed through the ordeal of fire and death at Mechanicsville
and Gaines' mill, and were now prepared for the worst. The regiments that supported them
were ordered to use only the bayonet against the enemy. In front of the batteries for
eight hundred yards was an open field, over which the enemy advanced against the most
terrific storm of grape and canister, that ever whirled in death-torrents across fields
of fiercest battle. The foe coming from the dense forests, rushed upon the guns with a
recklessness and contempt for death that surpassed the desperation of all other fields. In
an hour like that, when men in dense masses, maddened with the excitement of battle, rush
upon the fiery ordnance that at every round for a distance of a thousand yards, at point
blank range, with charges of double shotted grape and canister, plows a horrible furrow of
flesh and gore through the living field, artillerymen, like demons incarnate, revel amid
blood, groans, destruction, death, mangled forms, and fumes of
269
hell,
forgetful of danger, and glorying in the consciousness of superior strength. At each
charge on Cooper's and Kern's batteries, the artillery cleared, its front of living men,
and filled it with the dead and dying. The supporting regiments, inspired by the success
of the batteries, each time the enemy advanced fell upon the right and left of the
charging
column, while the artillery broke the centre and hurled it back in confusion across the
fields, into the forest.
For more than two hours of fearful
sacrifice, the enemy attempted to capture or drive from the field these two batteries, but
were unsuccessful. A terrible crisis was now reached. General Seymour had ordered the
caissons of Kern's battery to be taken to the rear. Captain Kern had nearly exhausted the
ammunition in his limbers; two officers had already been despatched in search of the
caissons, but had failed to find them. Captain Kern reported to General McCall that in a
few minutes his ammunition would be expended, and his caissons could not be found. The
battery was therefore ordered to move to the rear. Captain Kern fired his last charge, and
then, with a heart full of sorrow, and eyes swimming in tears, ordered his battery from
the field. It was about this time, that the regiments on the left had been forced back,
after their charge. The enemy seeing the battery wheeling from its position, charged with
great force from the right, on the artillery, but was again repulsed by the vigorous
counter charge of Colonel Roberts' regiment. As the regiment pursued the enemy towards the
woods, a fresh column of rebel troops, charging from the left, flanked it, and forced it
from the field; then rushing furiously on Captain Cooper's gunners, drove them from their
pieces and captured their battery. Just at this moment the Ninth regiment returned from
the left to its original position near Cooper's battery; the men were told that Cooper's
battery was lost; in one voice they demanded to be led to the charge, to recapture it.
Parts of other regiments formed in line with the Ninth, and rushed from the woods upon the
battery at the instant the enemy
270
was turning
the guns upon them, a tremendous cheer and an irresistible charge, and immediately the
undaunted Penn- sylvanians were in the very midst of the foe. A terrific contest ensued.
Bayonets thrust and parried; muskets were clubbed; pistols, daggers, and bowie knives were
freely used as the hostile currents surged in the turmoil of death, around and among the
guns and caissons; the Reserves had now determined the battery should be recaptured; the
Confederates were equally bent on not relinquishing their possession. Never did men fight
with more death-courting fury. On the right, Randall's battery was belching forth its
terrible charges of grape and canister; the enemy could spare no reinforcements from that
quarter; at the price of life the gallant Simmons had broken the power of the enemy on the
left, the centre now struggled alone. Too severe the storm, too fruitful of death the
conflict, for mortal to endure ! The rebels broke and run; with shouts of victory and
insatiate wrath, the men pursued them; across the field, through the woods, and into the
road, " going straight to Richmond," shooting them, bayoneting them, clubbing
them and running them down, till the officers, seizing the color-bearers, forced the
victorious heroes to return to their original line; but not until William J. Gallagher, a
private in Company F, who killed the rebel color-bearer, had seized the standard of the
Tenth Alabama regiment, and carried it from the field. The regiment was met by General
McCall and congratulated for its brilliant achievement. The general received from
private Gallagher the rebel colors and sent them to the rear.
The centre had nobly sustained
itself; the troops had repulsed the enemy at every charge, and had finally cleared their
front of hostile regiments.
After the rebel troops had
disappeared from the field in front of Cooper's battery, Colonel Roberts dressed his line,
and directed the officers near him to keep their men well in hand, to meet another charge,
in case the enemy renewed the conflict. It was after ,sunset ; the men knew the battle
271
could not be
continued much longer, and hence prepared for a final struggle. Just then a great noise
was heard oil the left and rear ; all eyes were instantly turned in that direction. Horror
seized the hearts of the wearied soldiers, and men stood fixed as statues. A brigade of
troops was pouring from the woods, marching under a banner of strange device, which in the
dusk of the evening could not be distinguished. " My God," exclaimed Colonel
Roberts, what is that?" The next moment the stars and stripes emerged from the
wood, and the answering shout went up: "It is the Irish brigade !" An officer
came dashing forward to Colonel Roberts, and said he had come to relieve his troops. The
First and Ninth, and portions of other regiments then retired to the wood and General
Meagher moved forward his brigade.
The enemy suddenly opened a most
terrific fire of shell, and grape and canister from the woods beyond the field. General
Meagher ordered his brigade to charge. "Save yourselves, men," said an officer
of the Reserves. " No!" replied Meagher, "rout the enemy! We fight for God!
America! and Old Ireland !" The "fighting Irishmen" threw aside their hats
and coats, rolled up their sleeves, gave a tremendous cheer, and then following their
gallant commander, charged across the field against the murderous fire of artillery, that
slew them by hundreds. But, braving death, on went the Irish brigade, over the field and
into the woods beyond; so completely routed the enemy, that he did not again renew the
conflict on that portion of the field.
During all the time of the severe
contest on the left, and the fierce battle in the centre, the right wing, commanded by
General Meade, had been vigorously engaged, and had succeeded in repulsing the enemy at
every charge. Thwarted in every attempt to turn the left, and repulsed in their charge
upon the centre, the columns of the enemy were now massed for a final desperate effort to
crush the regiments on the right, and sweep their fragments from the field. The shades
of evening were fast closing on the scene;
272
the roar of
battle had diminished into a desultory fire, On the centre and left were the debris of
exploded caissons and broken batteries, the carcasses of horses, and the bodies of dead
men, inextricably mixed. In front, an ominous silence reigned. That the enemy was about to
renew his favorite tactics, and hurl the whole weight of his powerful masses against a
selected point of the line, General McCall well knew, nor was he deceived in expecting
that the attack would be made on the right wing. The keen eye of General Meade bad
already detected the movements of the enemy, and instantly his lines were strengthened,
and every man and every gun was in position. The Fourth and the Seventh regiments, and
Captain Porter's and Lieutenant Sloan's companies of the Eleventh, lay in the woods behind
Randall's battery. In a few moments a brigade of the enemy, coming out from the forest on
the right of the field, six hundred yards from the battery, came forward at a full run,
trailing their arms, and in irregular masses rushed into the fight. Captain Randall and
his regulars, envying the laurels won by the volunteer. batteries on their left, strained
to their utmost power to sweep from the field the hordes of rebel troops, swarming on
their front. Showers of shot and shell, from rebel batteries, pouring over. the heads of
their charging column, tore and crashed through the trees around the battery and among the
infantry, doing but slight damage, to the Reserves. On came the infantry; the grape and
canister from Randall's guns at each round swept a channel of death through the mass of
men, from the front line to the borders of the forest, but on they came, screaming and
yelling like savages; closing up the terrible gaps as often as the death-path revealed
the dreadful carnage. The head of the column came within thirty-yards of the cannon's
mouth, but the fire was too terrible to endure, the brigade broke and scattered, but a
second brigade in supporting distance pushed boldly forward, it too reeled beneath the
fire, and was hurled back to, the woods by the charge of the Fourth regiment, A third and
more powerful brigade rushed.upon
273
the
regiment, and drove it behind the battery. Certain of victory, and maddened by the
destruction in their ranks, the infuriated rebels pressed onward, through the lake of
fire, and the atmosphere of death. They rushed upon the gunners with bayonet and knife;
the Seventh regiment and part of the Fourth and Eleventh fired a volley into the front of
the foe, at such short range, that the flames struck their faces. Regardless of
resistance, the rebels drove the cannoniers from their guns, and forced the infantry
from the field. General McCall and General Meade, who were on the ground, rallied the men
to the contest. Many of Captain Randall's men seized muskets and joined the infantry. A
heroic band was rallied to retake the battery. The men charged from the woods, and fell
upon the rebels just as one of the guns had been reversed, and its contents fired into the
National troops. A struggle for the possession of the battery immediately commenced.
Around the cannon, and over the dead bodies of horses and fallen comrades, the fierce
conflict rolled and raged with unparalleled fury. Few shots were fired. Bayonet crossed
bayonet, and sabre and knife flashed fire from their clashing edges; single combatants
stood breathless, face to face, and foot to foot, with locked bayonets, which each feared
to release lest the other should gain the advantage. A supernatural frenzy fired the
spirits of the men. The shouts of command, the shrieks and yells of the enemy, the cheers
of the Reserves, the flash of the sabre, the thrust and parry of the bayonet, the crash of
the clubbed musket, the spouting blood, the death cry, the rushing of masses, the
surging of the conflict, pressing back into the forest, and forward again to the fragments
of the broken battery, officers mounted on the guns cheering on their men, the momentary
lulls, the rally and the fierce renewal of the fight, made the scene a maelstrom of fury
with its currents of blood, wounds, and death, unparalleled in the history of the
rebellion.
General McCall had already put his
last man into the fight, and was therefore unable to reinforce the troops strug-
274
gling in a
death-grapple for Randall's battery. Fresh regiments reinforced the enemy's column, and
the Reserves. were borne from the field, and carried back into the woods by sheer force of
numbers. The rebels, however, had been too severely punished to pursue. They did not even
attempt to hold the battery, but abandoning all they had won, hastily fell back to the
woods, beyond the field; and hearing the cheers of a brigade of New Jersey troops which
was marching along the rear of McCall's position, to reinforce General Kearney's line,
the enemy did not venture to renew the conflict. The sun had already set, and as the dark
shadows drew close around the evening's twilight, the roar of battle grew gradually more
dim, and like the expiring day, glimmered and went out in the gloom of night.
In the last terrible conflict that
closed the battle of this day, an officer leading a Georgia regiment appeared most
conspicuous, cheering on his men. He was a giant in form and strength; he wore a plain
black coat, bearing no insignia of rank, and was armed with a musket and bayonet, which he
used with ferocious power to clear his way, bayoneting right and left as he advanced. He
was, however, soon confronted by Sergeant H. C. Howard, of the Eleventh Reserves, a young
man of undaunted courage and of great muscular strength. Howard had already, during the
day, despatched three men with his bayonet, and would not now shrink from the most
powerful enemy. The Georgian thrust at him with his bloody bayonet, but Howard dexterously
parried his stroke and caught the hostile weapon on the shank of his own. A desperate
trial of skill and strength ensued; the two giants wrestled in the embrace of death,
regardless of the fury of battle that surrounded them. Neither combatant would release the
other's weapon to hazard a thrust at his antagonist, and both bayonets were finally
brought to the ground. The two giants stood face to face, eyes glaring in stubborn
defiance at each other, fixed as statues. At this moment
275
one of
Howard's companions coming up to him, clubbed his musket, and struck the Georgian on the
head a blow that stretched him lifeless on the ground. Sergeant Howard then turned to
General McCall, near whom the contest had occurred, smiled and nodded his head
emphatically to one side, and again dashed away into the fight.
General Meade, who had done valiant
service, and who had been General McCall's chief reliance during the day,
was wounded
late in the evening, while cheering on his regiments to the last desperate conflict. He
was struck simultaneously by two balls, one entering his arm, and the other, penetrating
the body just above the hip joint, passed out near the spine. He attempted to remain on
the field,
but becoming
exhausted from loss of blood, rode to the rear alone, and was received at the hospital by
Surgeon Collins, who bound up his wounds, and sent him to the James river in an ambulance.
As soon as the enemy had left the
field, General McCall
commenced
the work of collecting his regiments, for the purpose of re-forming his line. He labored
under great disadvantages. He had lost all of his brigade commanders;
and in
addition to this, in the course of the day all the members of his staff had been killed,
wounded, or put hors du combat; his faithful orderly had been mortally wounded
at his side,
and his personal escort, a captain and twenty men of the Fourth cavalry, had been killed,
wounded or
dispersed,
two only excepted, and the general himself bad all day been under the hottest fire,
encouraging his men.
After the enemy had fallen back from
the left and centre, and hurled their forces against the right, the fragments of six
regiments on the left, joined themselves together under
their
ranking officers, formed an independent brigade, and moved to the front. There was 'now no
general officer on
the field to
command them. General Meade was wounded, Colonel Simmons, who commanded the First brigade,
was killed, and General Seymour, commanding the Third brigade, had become separated from
his troops and had left
276
the field.
When, therefore, the battle raged with terrible fury on the right, these troops, with one
accord, moved towards that part of the field, where General McCall was in the midst of the
carnage, superintending the fight. Before the troops reached the scene of the final
struggle, the battle had ended. When they gained their original position in the border of
the field, Major Stone rode forward to reconnoitre the ground in front; when he reached
the wrecks of the batteries on the crest of the hill, he was joined by General McCall, who
was attended by a corporal and a private of the Fourth Pennsylvania cavalry. They rode
forward a short distance, when they were suddenly confronted by the levelled muskets of
a column of rebel infantry, and commanded to halt and dismount. General McCall and the
two cavalrymen, who were in front of Major Stone, were captured. Two volleys were fired at
the major, but, it being now quite dark, he escaped, slightly wounded.
The several regiments had now
collected on the road near the right of the line; the commanders of the regiments, unable
to learn of the fate of the general officers, and being without orders, collected their
troops for such resistance as it was possible for them to make. Colonel Roberts, who was
the ranking officer on the field, assumed command, and directed the men to form on the
road and await his orders. About ten o'clock, General Seymour, coming up the road from the
rear, arrived on the field, and relieving Colonel Roberts , took command of the shattered
columns of the Reserves. The enemy had fallen back half a mile from the battle-field,
which became neutral, or, at least, unoccupied ground, until late in the night, the enemy
moved up a division of fresh troops to hold the field.
The Reserves remained in position on
the right and centre, on a line about one hundred yards in rear of the original line of
battle, until eleven o'clock in the night, when they were ordered to withdraw and follow
the other divisions of the army to Malvern hill. Before leaving the field, tha artillery
officers asked permission to procure
277
horses and
men to bring away their batteries, which were in front of the infantry, having been left
there in the evening, because the horses had been killed and the men were unable to draw
them fror4 the field. General Heintzelman, however, refused to allow the artillerymen to
attempt to remove the guns, lest it would bring on a renewal of the battle; and General
McClellan had directed General Heintzelman to avoid a general engagement until the army
reached a position on the James river, where it could be; aided by the gunboats. The
artillery with McCall's division was therefore abandoned by the Army of the Potomac; it
was not captured; but, on the morning of the 1st of July, was found on the field by the
enemy's pickets.
Among the noble dead left on this
field of blood, was Colonel Seneca G. Simmons. In the death of this officer, the Reserves
lost an able and an experienced man, of the highest military attainments, and universally
acknowledged soldierly qualifications. His education was altogether military. He left
Vermont, his native State, at the age of fourteen, and became a pupil of Captain
Partrige's school, then located in Connecticut, and., removed from thence, with a
branch of
that institution to Georgetown, D. C. While there, he formed that love of military life
which decided his fate. Going alone, and unaided, to President Jackson, he asked, and
received from him, the appointment of cadet, to the United States Military Academy at West
Point. He graduated in 1834, and was assigned to the Seventh regiment of infantry in the
United States Army. He had been almost constantly on duty. Previous to the war, every
inducement had been urged in order to secure his services to the Confederate cause, but
he scorned alike offers of place or high rank, where there might lurk even a suspicion of
treason to his beloved flag, and turned a deaf ear to all persuasions of old companions in
arms, though endeared by ties of long friendship, cemented by the hardships and dangers of
the camp, or the more quiet enjoyments of garrison life. He served in the campaigns of
Florida and Mexico, and by
278
gallant
conduct won the rank of captain, but his life had been spent chiefly on frontier duty,
remote from the influences of luxury, political intrigue or its aspiration, and he
therefore brought to the aid of. the Union cause, all the enthusiasm and loyalty which had
animated his youth. When the darkening ; shadows of coming events," told us the
dread storm of war was inevitable, and the thunder of the traitors' cannon broke on
Sumter, Captain Simmons, was with his family in Harrisburg, and rendered important
service, during the organization of the first troops, that responded to the call of their
Government. He identified himself with the Pennsylvania Reserves, from their earliest
formation, was elected colonel of the Fifth infantry, and assisted with all his powers, to
bring that portion of the army to the efficiency of veteran troops. In personal
appearance N. P. Willis, who saw him during a review in a storm, thus describes him:
" Of a most warlike caste of feature, his profuse, and slightly grizzled beard, was
impearled with glistening drops, and with horse and accoutrements all dripping, he rode
calmly through the heavy rain, like a Triton, taking, his leisure in his native element.
It was the finest of countenances, and the
best of figures, for a horseman. He looked indomitable in spirit, and unsubject to the
common inconveniences of humanity, as handsome and. brave, when tired and wet, as he
would when happy and dry." He adds, I was quite captivated -with the picture of
such a man, and did not wonder at the comment appended to the reply of a subaltern officer
of whom I enquired his name: General Simmons,' said he, 'a man who everybody would
be glad to serve under."' The man mistook his rank, although frequently acting as
brigadier, he did not receive the appointment, though no braver man ever drew sword in
any cause, and no purer libation of love, and loyalty, was ever poured upon the altar of
his country, then flowed from the heart of Colonel Seneca G. Simmons.
Captain Henry J. Biddle, Assistant
Adjutant-General on General McCall's staff; was severely wounded in the charge
279
led by
Colonel Simmons. When the army moved to the James, he, with many others who could not be
removed, fell into the hands of the enemy; he was taken to Richmond, where he died on the
20th of July, 1862. Captain Biddle lead received a military education at West Point, and
had
for several
years been a civil engineer on the railroads in the State of Pennsylvania, and afterwards
became one of the firm of Thomas Biddle & Co., bankers and brokers in Philadelphia.
When the war began in 1861, he was appointed
au assistant
adjutant-general with the rank of captain, and assigned for duty to the Reserve corps. His
thorough knowledge of military, duties rendered him a most valuable officer in the work of
organizing the division. After the troops entered the field, and engaged in active
campaigns, Captain Biddle rose to distinction for meritorious and gallant conduct in the
most desperate battles of the war.
Near the close of the engagement
Colonel Hays, commanding the Eighth regiment, was leading his men to a
charge on
the right, when his horse was struck by a shell, and torn to pieces under him. Colonel
Hays received a severe bruise, and was saved, snatched from the jaws of death by Wilson
Cooper, a private in the regiment, who extricated him from the fragment's of his horse,
and carried him to the rear, but he was so seriously injured by the fall, that he did not
recover for many months, and was unable again to enter the service.
The horses attached to one of the
caissons of Randall's battery, maddened by a volley of musketry, which struck them and
killed their driver, dashed through the lines of the Seventh regiment, and inflicted
severe injuries on many of the men. The caisson passed over Colonel Harvey and bruised him
so severely that he was carried from the field.
During the
day, many officers of lower rank were killed and many more were wounded. Companies were
without
captains,
some without a commissioned officer to command them; regiments were without colonels, and
at the close of
280
the battle
the division was left without a general officer to lead it.
An officer in the Confederate army
reporting the battles of the Peninsula, says of the battle of New Market crossroads:
"General McClellan had taken his
position on the New Market road which formed his centre. This point he had strengthened
with nineteen pieces of heavy artillery, had collected his best troops there, and firmly
and coolly awaited our attack. We had, at all hazards, to drive the enemy from the
neighborhood of our Capital, or succumb ourselves. No other choice remained for us. During
the four days of massacre that had already passed, our troops had been transformed into
wild beasts, and hardly had they caught sight of the enemy, drawn up in order, ere they
rushed upon them with horrible yells. Yet calmly, as on the parade ground, the latter
delivered their fire. The batteries in the centre discharged their murderous volleys on
our men, and great disorder ensued among the storming masses. General Lee sent all his
disposable troops to the rescue, but McClellan opened upon these newly formed storming
columns so hellish a fire that even the coldest blooded veteran lost his
self-possession. Whole ranks of our men were hurled to the ground. The thunder of the
cannon, the crackling of the musketry from a hundred thousand combatants, mingled with the
screams of the wounded and the dying, were terrific to the ear and the imagination. Thus
raged the conflict within a comparatively narrow space seven long hours, and yet not a
foot of ground was won. All our reserves had been led into the fight, and the brigade of
Wilcox was annihilated. At length the corning of night compelled a truce, and, utterly
overcome by fatigue, the soldier sank upon the ground at his post, thoughtless of even the
friend torn from his side, and engrossed only with the instinct of self-preservation. Put
"water! water !'; was the cry from the parched lips on all sides. The empty flasks
contained not a drop, alas! and at length sleep overcame each worn-
281
out warrior,
and even thirst and hunger were forgotten. Gloomy and out of humor, General Lee rode
through the camping ground of the decimated regiments, attended by his staff, and then,
with a dry, harsh voice, ordered up the divisions of Wise and Magruder to bury the dead.
With a brief remark, he next indicated to General Longstreet his position for the next
day, and rode off with his aids to visit other portions of the line.''
The battle of New Market cross-roads
was reported by the enemy, as having been one of the most remarkable long contested, and
gallant fights, that had yet occurred on their lines. "General Longstreets and
General Hill's troops were
in such a
condition of prostration from their long and toilsome fight, and suffering in killed and
wounded, that they were unable to occupy the battlefield. When., therefore, at eleven
o'clock in the night, General Magruder arrived, his troops were sent forward to hold the
grounds in front."
General McCall thus reports the
battle to General Porter
On Friday evening, Tune 27th, after
the battle of Gaines' mills, my division crossed the Chickahominy at Trent's hill, where
it remained on picket duty till eight o'clock, P. ll., on the 28th. At that hour I
received your orders to move in the direction of White Oak creek, and to take with me
Hunt's reserve artillery, consisting of thirteen batteries. As this would extend my column
many miles in length, and as my flank would constantly be exposed to attack, I placed the
whole of the Third brigade, by regiments, between the batteries, to afford them support.
This movement, owing to narrow and bad roads, was necessarily slow, and my division,
after being all night on the march, did not reach the crossing of White Oak creek until
near noon on the 29th. Having crossed the creek, I was ordered by the general-in-chief to
put nay division in position to repel any attack by the enemy from the direction of
Richmond. This I did, and I remained in position till five o'clock, P. M. At that hour the
march was resumed and continued by my command till I reached the Quaker road crossing of
the New Market road, at midnight. My orders were to take a position here to repel an
attack from Richmond. Having selected my position and established the First and Second
brigades, and sent to the front a regiment of infantry and a battery, and a strong
picket in advance of them, I kept the Third brigade in reserve, and awaited the result
till near daylight, when I was ordered to return. I marched back, left in front, and
reached the point where the Turkey bridge road turns off from the
282
was ordered
to halt till the whole of the immense supply trains of the Army of the Potomac, then
slowly advancing from white Oak creek, had passed toward the James river, and to repel any
attack that the enemy might make on it. At nine o'clock, commenced the heavy cannonade,
caused by the enemy attempting to force the passage of the creek, and it continued with
little interruption till noon.
It was a determined artillery duel,
but as I did not apprehend their ability to effect a passage, I at once came, to the
conclusion that any attack on myself must come from the direction of Richmond, on my right
flank. I had thrown out a cavalry picket in that direction, and on afterward detecting
indications of an advance of the enemy, moved out a regiment of infantry to strengthen the
picket.
Having examined the country around
me, I made the disposition of my troops, facing to the right flank, as follows : Meade 's
brigade on the right, Seymour's on the left, and held Reynolds' brigade, non' commanded
by Colonel Seneca G. Simmons, of the Fifth, in reserve. The artillery I established in
front of the line, Randall's (regular) battery on the right, Cooper's and Kern's opposite
the centre, and two German batteries, (accidentally with my division,) of four
twenty-pound Parrott guns each, commanded by Captains Dietrich and Kennerheim, on the
left of the infantry line.
The Fourth regiment Pennsylvania
cavalry, Colonel Childs, was drawn up on the left and rear, but not being called into
action, was subsequently ordered to fall back.
The country on my new front was open,
embracing a large farm, intersected toward the right by the New Market road and a small
strip of timber parallel to it; the open front was eight hundred yards, its depth at least
one thousand yards. It was a beautiful battle-field, but too large for my force, the lands
on either flank being open. My disposition having been made, I calmly awaited the approach
of the enemy.
About half-past two o'clock, P. M.,
my picket8, after skirmishing, were driven in by a strong advance, but without loss on our
side. At three o'clock, the enemy sent forward a regiment on my left centre, and
immediately afterward another on my right centre, to feel for a weak point. They were
under cover of a shower of shell, and advanced boldly, but were both driven back, the
former by the Third regiment, Colonel Sickel, and the latter by the Seventh regiment,
Colonel Harvey. After this, I rode forward with the First Rifles, a0d placed them in a
narrow skirt of timber on the left and in front. Soon after this, a very heavy column
moved to the left of my line, and tL3reatened to take me in flank. I at once changed front
on that flank, sending Colonel Simmons with two regiments of the First brigade to
reinforce that quarter. This movement was promptly executed, but not a moment too soon,
for a furious attack with artillery and infantry was almost immediately made on that
flank. I, at the same time, directed Captain Biddle,
283
assistant
adjutant-general, to ride to the left and change the direction of fire of the two German
batteries from the front to the left. This order was gallantly executed, but it is with
deep grief that I have to state that this brave and valuable officer fell here mortally
wounded.
For nearly two hours the battle raged
fiercely, the enemy throwing in a perfect storm of shot and shell, and making several
attempts to force my position. Always checked by the steadiness of my brave Reserves, he
at last retired for a time, driven back by the well-directed fire of musketry. During this
attack, the gallant and lamented Colonel Simmons fell, also mortally wounded.
It must not be imagined that the
enemy was inactive along the centre and right of my line during all this time. Cooper's
and Kern's batteries, in front of the centre, were boldly charged upon, each time a
regiment dashing up to within fifty or forty yards. They were then hurled back by a storm
of canister and the deliberate fire of the First regiment, Colonel Roberts, whom I had
placed immediately in rear of Bern's, and the Ninth regiment, Colonel Jackson, in rear of
Cooper's. The contest was severe, and put the steadiness of these regiments to the test;
both
suffered heavy loss, but particularly the First regiment, whose gallant lieutenant-colonel
(McIntyre) was severely wounded.
Some time after this, the most
determined charge of the day was made upon Randall's battery, by a full brigade, advancing
in wedge shape, without order, but with a wild recklessness that I never saw equalled.
Somewhat similar charges had, as I have stated, been previously made on Cooper's and on
Kern's batteries, by single regiments,
without
success, the Confederates having been driven back with heavy loss. A like result appears
to have been anticipated by Randall's company; and the Fourth regiment (as was
subsequently reported to me) was requested not to advance between the guns, as I had
ordered, as it interfered with the cannoniers, but to let the battery deal with them. Its
gallant commander did not doubt, I am satisfied, his ability to repel the attack, and his
guns fairly opened lanes in the advancing host. These gaps were, however, immediately
closed, and the enemy came on, with arms trailed, at a run, to the very muzzles of his
guns, where they pistoled or bayoneted the cannoniers. Two guns were limbered, and were in
the act of wheeling to the rear when the horses were shot, the guns were both overturned,
and presented one confused heap of men, horses and carriages. Over all these the men of
the Eleventh Alabama regiment dashed in, a perfect torrent of men, and I am sorry to say
the greater part of the Fourth regiment gave way. The left company, Captain Conrad, of
that regiment, however, stood its ground, and with some fifty or eighty men of other
companies met the Alabamians.
I had ridden into the regiment and
endeavored to check them; but, as is Seen, with only partial success. It was here,
however, my fortune to witness between those of my men who stood their ground and the
284
rebels who
advanced, one of the fiercest bayonet fights that perhaps ever occurred on this continent.
Bayonets were crossed and locked in the. struggle; bayonet wounds were freely given and
received. I saw skulls crushed by the heavy blow of the butt of the musket, and, in short,
the desperate thrusts and parries of a life-and-death encounter, proving, indeed, that
Greek had met Greek when the Alabama boys fell upon the sons of Pennsylvania.
My last reserve regiment I had
previously sent to support Cooper, and I had not now a man to bring forward. My men were
bodily home off the ground by superior numbers. A thick wood was immediately in rear, and
the Confederates did not follow my men into the thicket. It was at this moment, on
witnessing the scene I have described, that I bitterly felt that my division ought to have
been reinforced.
My force had been reduced, by the
battles of the 26th and 27th, to less than six thousand, and on this occasion I had to
contend with the divisions of Longstreet anal A. P. Hill, estimated amongst the strongest
and best of the Confederate army, and numbering that day from eighteen to twenty thousand.
The centre was at this time still
engaged and I could not withdraw any troops from it.
The Alabama troops did not attempt to
enfilade my line, and leaving the guns on the ground, (the horses having, during the
fight, been either killed or dispersed,) they retired to the woods on my right.
It was now near sunset, and the heat
of battle had greatly subsided. I now rode to the rear to rally and collect the
stragglers. At a short distance I came upon two regiments of Kearny's division. I
requested them to move forward, but was informed their orders were to await the arrival of
General Kearny. I moved on and set some officers at work to form the stragglers of my own
regiments into line. On my return I found General Kearny. Ile put his regiments in motion
and moved to the front and on the right of my line.
As he rode away, he said to me:
" If you can bring forward another line in a few minutes, we can stop them." By
this time the sun had set, and the desultory firing was confined to the extreme right.
In a short time Lieutenant-Colonel
Thompson, Third regiment, came up and reported to me that he had collected about five
hundred men, with whom he was then advancing. I rode on with him at the head of the
column, in a direction to bring this force up on Kearny's left.
On arriving near the ground where
Randall's battery stood, I halted Thompson's command, wishing to ascertain whether any of
my men were still in front of me. I had left Captain Conrads company about one
hundred yards in advance, but it was now so dark I could scarcely distinguish a man at ten
paces. The battle, in fact, was now over; the firing on the left and centre had ceased,
and there was only a desultory firing between Kearny's men and the enemy, some distance to
my right. I rode forward to look for Conrad, and on the ground where I left him
285
I rode into
the enemy's picket, the Forty-seventh Virginia, Colonel Mayo, resting under some trees,
and before I knew in whose presence I was, I was taken prisoner. Unfortunately for myself,
I had no staff officer with me, or I should have sent him forward to examine the ground,
instead of going myself; but my adjutant-general, the valiant Captain Henry J. Biddle, had
been mortally wounded; Lieutenant Sheetz had his horse killed, and was injured by the
fall; my chief of ordnance, the gallant Beatty, had been severely wounded at my side, and
only left me when I had insisted on his doing so; my excellent orderly, Sergeant Simeon
Dunn, Fourth Pennsylvania cavalry, was also fatally wounded.at my side, and out of my
escort of a captain and twenty men of the Fourth cavalry, but one corporal (the brave
King) and one private remained with me; these two men were made prisoners with myself.
About the time I was taken prisoner, the desultory firing on my right died away.
The conduct of the Pennsylvania Reserves on this hard fought field is worthy of all praise, as is fully attested by their stubborn resistance and their heavy loss in killed and wounded. Besides the officers I have already named, I am greatly indebted to the gallant commander of the Second brigade, General George G. Meade, who rendered me efficient aid until his wounds compelled him to leave the field. My thanks are likewise due to Colonel Roberts, commanding First regiment; Colonel Sickel, commanding Third regiment; Colonel Hays, commanding Eighth regiment; Colonel Jackson and Captain Cuthbertson, of the Ninth regiment, and other brave officers not commanding regiments, of whom Lieutenant-Colonel McIntyre, Major George A. Woodward and Major Woolworth are among the many wounded. I must also name as entitled to. favorable notice, Acting Division Surgeon Stocker, who accompanied me in the early part of the day, and assisted in communicating my orders until slightly wounded in the wrist by the fragment of a shell. Indeed, to all are my best thanks and praises due for bravely contributing to the important results, namely, the defence of the immense supply train while passing that point, and the holding the enemy in check upon the New Market road, where he strove desperately to cut in two the retiring column of the Army of the Potomac.
The trophies of the day were three
stands of colors captured, and about two hundred prisoners.
The loss of the division in killed,
wounded, and prisoners, in the three battles of the 26th, 27th and 30th of June, was three
thousand one hundred and eighty, the killed and wounded amounting to one thousand six
hundred and fifty, out of about seven thousand who went into battle at Mechanicsville on
the 26th of June.
I am, very respectfully,
Your obedient servant,
GEORGE A. McCALL.
286
General McClellan, who was not
present at the battle of New Market cross roads, and, having been misinformed as to the
nature of the conflict, and the conduct of the troops engaged, misrepresented, in his
report, the action of the Reserve Corps, in language wholly unwarranted. General Hooker
and General Heintzelman, who were on the left and rear of General McCall's division, in
their attempt to report an engagement which they had not witnessed, and of the character
of which they had no trustworthy information, also grossly misstated the conduct of the
troops.
That these officers, from whose
reports it would appear that the Pennsylvania Reserves failed to sustain their honorable
reputation in this severe engagement, are in error, there is abundant evidence.
When General McCall was captured, he
was taken to General Lee's headquarters, where General Long street told him that,
"Lee had seventy-five thousand troops bearing on that point, all of whom would arrive
before midnight, and had he succeeded in forcing McClellan's column of march, they would
have been thrust in between the right and left wing of the Federal army." It was the
firm resistance made by the Reserves that defeated this purpose of the enemy, which, if it
had succeded, would have resulted in the destruction of the Army of the Potomac.
Surgeon Marsh, of the Fourth
regiment, remained in
chare of the
wounded at Willis' church, and fell into the hands of the enemy. He was ordered to report
to General Lee on the New Market road. At Lee's headquarters, Surgeon Marsh met General
Longstreet, who inquired of him whether he had been present at the engagement ; also what
troops had been engaged. He replied that he had been in the battle, and knew only of the
action of McCall's division, which had fought on the grounds they were then standing on.
"Well," said Longstreet, "McCall is safe in Richmond, but if his division
had not offered the stubborn resistance it did, on this road, we would have captured your
whole army.
287
General Fitz John Porter, in a report
of the operations on the left of the army, on the 30th of June, made to General
McClellan on the 6y.h of July, says: " McCall's division, posted on the New Market
road to cover the withdrawal of our trains, was attacked by the enemy in immense force. He
maintained his place till nightfall, when the surviving portion of his command rejoined
the corps, coming in under the command of Brigadier-general Seymour, the only remaining
general officer on duty; " and in a letter dated at Washington, October 20, 1862, he
says: 'Had not McCall held his place on New Market road, June 30, that line of march
of the (Federal) army would have been cut by the enemy."
General Meade, writing from "
Camp near Warrenton, Va.," November 7, 1862, says: "It was only the stubborn
resistance offered by our division (the Pennsylvania Reserves), prolonging the contest
till after dark, and checking till that time the advance of the enemy, that enabled the
concentration during the night of the whole army on James river, which saved it."
Lieutenant E. Beatty, ordnance
officer on General McCall's staff; wrote from Carlisle, on the 12th of July, 1862, the
following
" The battle of the 30th (which
opened about four P. M.) was in my opinion the most desperate of the three battles in
which the "Reserves" were engaged. Our position was one of great responsibility
in reference to the safety of the whole army. General McCall fully appreciated it, and the
military proportions of the old hero loomed up to the grandeur of the occasion. I3is whole
manner and appearance evinced ,the determination to triumph or die. As the battle
progressed the whole energy of the veteran soldier was roused. He entered into the
thickest and hottest of the conflict with intense earnestness and entirely regardless of
peril, although all the time in the midst of a tempest of deadly missiles. The portion of
the field to which he gave his personal attention was our centre and right, and
288
our troops were cheered by his constant presence with them. He rode from regiment to regiment, and dashed along, shouting words of encouragement to inspirit both officers and men. At times under the fierce onsets of the desperate rebel foe our ranks would reel, and stagger, and fall back. But most active of all in checking the stampede and turning back the fugitives was their veteran general himself. And his presence and rallying cry was most potent in bringing them again to ` a stand.' Then regaining their self-possession, and speedily re-forming their line they would again rush forward with cheers and drive back the rebel desperadoes. About six o'clock P. M., I received a rifle ball through the thigh of my right leg. The general urged me to go to the rear and find a surgeon at once. But as I felt no bone was broken, I determined not to le