Miller, William J. "Bucktail Summer." Civil War 63 (Aug 1997)
This morning by the edge of a Maryland
cornfield would bring to a close the summer campaigns of 1862 - three months of marching
and fighting that, for these men, had been a transformation of unusual severity. No longer
were they untested innocents eager to see battle. They were now veterans, and if anyone
had that morning reminded them of General George McClellan's pronouncement that it would
take five years to make a volunteer into a reliable soldier, they might well have replied
with loud guffaws. General McClellan had not been in the places they had been that summer.
He had not seen what they had seen nor endured what they had been through. Few regiments
in either army had. If the men in the woods that September morning were not yet soldiers,
then there was not a soldier on the continent.
His name was Bucktail, and he was born in
Pennsylvania, or Maryland or Virginia, sometime in 1861, though just when is hard to say.
He began as a mass of a couple of thousand legs, eyes and hands and half that many hearts,
but at some point in that first year of the Civil War he became an entity unto himself,
bigger and stronger than the sum of its parts. The
new persona transcended the individual limitations of the loggers, rivermen, farmers,
shop clerks and roustabouts who had combined to make it and became the brotherhood of the
Bucktail the embodiment of all the brash, arrogant, muscular, masculine conceit the
mountains of northern Pennsylvania could produce.
Bucktail was fathered outside a butcher shop in
Smethport, Pennsylvania, when James Landregan took a fancy to the tail of a hanging deer
carcass. He sliced it off, pinned it to his cap and created an
instant craze. Whether Landregan was boasting of his prowess as a hunter (many of the men
from the wild mountains spent long days in the woods with a rifle, and they were proud of
their marksmanship) or merely affecting a quasi-military ornament ---a poor rustic's
version of the British Army's bearskin hats ---- his flourish captured the imagination of
his comrades. They stripped the deer naked and adorned themselves with hanks of fur. In
time, they would find genuine tails or write home to ask fathers, brothers or cousins to
send them one. No man in the regiment wished to be without the badge that marked him as a
part of Bucktail.
There was not a regiment in
America-in 1861 not filled with naïve arrogance and foolish notions of whipping 10 times
its own number in the battles to come, but few volunteers were more supremely certain of
their superiority than the men who became the 13th Pennsylvania alias, 42nd Pennsylvania
Infantry, 1st Pennsylvania Rifles or Kane Rifle Regiment, known to friends and enemies as
"the Bucktails." Most regiments that had the chance to test themselves in battle
had the nonsense knocked out of them soon enough, but Bucktail, as he sometimes called
himself, seems never to have been willing to admit that he was not as good as he thought
he was.
He first descended upon the civilized
world in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, where his rugged appearance and his rustic headgear
caused a sensation. Newspapermen and citizens saw that here was a set of fighting men with
style and spirit. That they were expert marksmen, or at least claimed to be, contributed
to their celebrity, and the story of Bucktail spread as far as the local newspapers and
word of mouth could carry it. After Bucktail learned that civilians were apt to view his
antics with a wink and smile, he enlivened the weeks in training camp with drunken brawls,
raids on nearby farms and gardens and occasional rebellions against authority. He had only
contempt for the rules of discipline and regularly went absent without leave for an
evening to seek his pleasures outside camp. "The guard appreciates that confinement
is not conducive to Bucktail's happiness," one man wrote, "and Bucktail breathes
the free air of heaven without restraint. If his steps are arrested
As Bucktail's fame spread, his ego
fattened. A train ride through soutern Pennsylvania led a sergeant to
declare that "All along our route the people turned out by the thousands
to get a glimpse of the
Bucktails." When the regiment reached Washington, the men found they were
celebrities, On the streets of the capital, "every little boy we met hallowed out,
'go it, Bucktails,' or 'Bully for the Bucktails." The few times the regiment
skirmished with Southerners that first year
of the war, Bucktail believed he saw the enemy "scatter like frightened sheep"
soon after the fight began. The explanation? "He did not know he had Bucktails to
deal with." Nor did the bloody skirmishes dampen Bucktail's ardor. After a long fight
at Dranesville, Virginia, in December 1861, Private William Clark declared, 'We are ready
for another fight at the first opportunity."
By the spring of 1862, when the regiment reached Falmouth,
Virginia---of which one of the men remarked, "It would be hard to imagine a more
miserable, God-forsaken place "--Bucktail was a fully developed persona, as cock-sure
and bumptious as he had been at enlistment a year earlier. It was at Falmouth, however,
that Bucktail's initiation to the hardships of war was to begin in earnest. The first blow
came from within.
Since the regiment's formation
the men had been of two minds regarding their commanding officers. Thomas Lieper Kane,
the man who brought the Bucktails together, had been elected colonel in June 1861, but
since his military experience consisted entirely of throwing rocks at Parisian
policemen as a college student in France, he had declined the post in favor of Charles
J. Biddle, a Philadelphia lawyer with command experience in the Mexican War. Kane, the son of a judge, was also a lawyer and an ambi.tious man,
and might have realized that deferring to Biddle, scion of a powerful and well-connected
family, would do him no harm, especially since Biddle would be standing for election to
Congress in the fall. Kane accepted the lieutenant colonelcy and bided his time.
Somehow, the upper class Philadelphian proved
immensely popular with the woodsmen and mountaineers from the wildest part of
Pennsylvania. I have never yet seen his
superior, wrote a sergeant. He
is just the man we want. Another man
thought Biddle was idolized by the men: never was a regiment more attached to their
commander, for never was an officer more considerate of the comfort of the men, or more
attentive to the advancement of their military character. Biddle professed to return their devotion.
"Next to my family," he told them in October 1861, "1 love this regiment
best: I am resolved with you to conquer, or with you to die." Within weeks, his
resolve apparently having dissolved, he resigned to assume his seat in Congress. The
Bucktails buried their sorrow in metaphors: "A boy of ten years might better lose his
father and mother," wrote one, "and be thrown penniless upon the world than we
to lose our little Colonel."
Lieutenant Colonel Kane took command of the
regiment - a change not popular among all the men. Some admired him, pointing to his two
wounds from a skirmish. "He is emphatically a fighting man," one man thought.
"Lieutenant Col. Kane is a gentleman and one of the bravest officers in the
division; and one who will not ask a man to go where he does not take the lead
himself."
Many more of the Bucktails,
however, thought differently. "Ever since the resignation of Col. Biddle,"
wrote one man, "it has been evident that our Lieut. Col. was a man wholly unfit to
be at the head of the regiment. He lacks that coolness of purpose and fairness of
decision, so requisite in a military commander.
The result of the rift in the regiment was that Kane has to stand for election to
colonel. The well-liked Captain Hugh McNeil
of Company D, a pre-war bank cashier with no prior military experience, opposed Kane. Despite Kanes vigorous electioneering---one man
declared he did not scruple to use any means to carry the election, and used
every influence that money, position and whiskey produce," - McNeil won election to
colonel with 64 percent of the votes cast.
The trouble at Falmouth came when McNeil went
on sick leave with typhoid fever. The unchastened Kane, through back-channel machinations,
gained permission to
Kane's strong-arm tactics earned for Bucktail
the distinction of being the only Federal outfit to participate in the Shenandoah Valley
Campaign and the Peninsula Campaign, both of
which would climax in June of 1862. For almost three months Confederate Major General
Thomas J. "Stonewall" Jackson had been keeping Federal armies off balance in the
Shenandoah. The Federal War department decided to send reinforcements to the Valley in
late May to corral Jackson once and for all. Thus went Kane and his 200 or s6riflemen to
the Shenandoah to play a small but significant
part in one of the more important campaigns of the war.
Kane managed to have his battalion attached to
Brigadier General George D. Bayard's "Flying Brigade," which was composed of the
Ist Pennsylvania and 4th New Jersey Cavalry regiments and a battery of Maine Light
Artillery. It was the only brigade in the army that mixed all three arms together, so in
that respect Kane's "experimental rifle tactics" were novel indeed. In truth,
the experiment tested legs and lungs more than rifles. Bucktail spent the first week of
June trotting over mile after mile of the Valley Turnpike and surrounding farmland trying
to keep up with his equine brigade mates. He marched more than 60 miles in five days,
leaving perhaps half his number lying by the roadside, victims of too much sun and too
little water or rest. On the sixth day, Bucktail fought.
General Bayard and his horsemen had hounded
Jackson as he withdrew southward, and on June 6, the 4th New Jersey pursued
Jackson decisively defeated the Federals the
next day at the Battle of Port Republic, but Bucktail would take no part in the fight.
Within days, the battalion was withdrawing with the rest of the Federal army, northward,
away from Jackson and out of the Valley he had won. Jackson, too, would soon move out of
the Valley, not to lick his wounds and collect his stragglers as the Federals were hoping
to do, but to combine with Robert E. Lee to change the course of the war.
The Confederate capital at Richmond, 90 miles
east of the Shenandoah Valley, was in June 1862 beset by the enormous Federal army of
Major General George B. McClellan. Lee decided his only chance to save the city from
Federal capture was to attack. He planned to strike on June 26. There to meet him would be
Major Roy Stone's Bucktails.
Major General George McCall had bought his
9,000-man division of Pennsylvania Reserves to the Peninsula in midjune, among them were
the six Bucktail companies left at Falmouth under Major Stone. just as fate had led Kane
and his Bucktails to contribute briefly but significantly to the history of the Valley
Campaign, so would it give them a place of distinction in the week-long running fight
known as the Seven Days Battles. On June 26 Bucktail was on picket at Meadow Bridges north
of Richmond, directly in the path of Lee's assaults.
The fight, generally known as Mechanicsville,
was chaotic from the outset. Confederates forced their way across the Chickahominy River,
driving the Bucktails and other pickets before them. Major Stone succeeded in
withdrawing three of his companies of Bucktails to the strong positions at Beaver Dam
Creek east o
Bucktail's five remaining companies had made it
to Beaver Dam Creek on June 26 in disarray Major Stone had fled across a swamp and only
escaped by abandoning his mare and a boot in the mire. Despite their adventures that
afternoon, the Bucktails found their work was just begun. With the rest of the
Pennsylvania Reserves, Stone's men filed into rifle pits and began laying down a
Lee resumed the fight the next morning, pushing
hard against the Federal defenses. just before dawn on June 27, the Pennsylvanians had
received word from army headquarters to withdraw from Beaver Dam Creek. The Confederate
attacks added to the chaos of changing a position in haste, and once again the Bucktails
suffered. "Our deadly fire could not keep back the overwhelming numbers of the enemy,
By the time Stone and his men
reached the new Federal line above Boatswain Creek, they numbered just 131, about half the
number of Bucktails who had begun the day in the rifle pits at Beaver Dam. Company E had
been cut off, as Company K had been the day before, and the Southerners sent another
portion of Bucktail to prison in Richmond. The rest of Stone's battalion skirmished in the
afternoon during the enormous Battle of Gaines's Mill. Lee again lost heavily, but ended
the day with his first victory. One hundred and eleven Bucktails ended the day dead,
wounded or in captivity.
Two more days of fighting and marching brought
the Seven Days Battles to a climax on June 30 at the crossroads known as Glendale. The
Southerners attacked with exceptional ferocity, and once again McCall's Pennsylvanians
bore the brunt of the attacks. Since Gaine's Mill, Major Stone had collected stragglers
and other wayward Bucktails until he could put 155 officers and men in line near the Long
Bridge Road. Though Bucktail was small that day, he fought large. He helped blunt a Confederate assault on the Federal left and rallied other commands broken
by the Southern onslaught. When forced to withdraw, Bucktail reformed and became the
nucleus of a hodgepodge of refugees from other regiments who returned to the fight and
helped keep the attackers at bay until darkness ended the fighting. Glendale saw some of
the more desperate fighting of the war, and casualties were high. Perhaps no unit on the
field suffered a higher proportional loss than Bucktail. When Stone counted heads the next
day, he found but 63 men present. In all, the six Bucktail companies that began the Seven
Days Battles lost 247 officers and men in five days of action, a casualty rate of 80
percent. When Colonel McNeil returned from sick leave, he stood with tears in his eyes and
said, "My God, where are my Bucktails?"
Thankfully, July passed uneventfully for
Bucktail, excepting the several score of men in prison in Richmond. After a few weeks, the
Confederates exchanged most of their captives and the stray Bucktails returned to the
fold. Lieutenant Colonel Kane was among them, and, though still hobbled by his wound, he
rejoined his little battalion in Major General John Pope's Army of Virginia.
On the black, rainy night of
The darkness made it difficult to tell friend
from foe. Horses and mules ran loose through the camp, silhouetted before burning wagons
and terrified by the flashes of gunfire. "The shooting and shouting of the men,"
thought one Confederate, "the braying of the mules, the glare of the lightning and
roll of the thunder, made it seem like all Pandemonium had broken loose." Kane and
his men put up a fight, discouraging, if not actually preventing, the Confederates from
firing the bridge (one raider thought that in such a rain storm "they might just as
well have tried to burn the creek!"). When the Southerners withdrew, they left the
bridge standing but took with them many horses, much equipment and 300 prisoners, 19 of
whom belonged to Kane. Catlett was another hard knock in Bucktail's education.
And there were more to come. After delivering
Richmond, Robert E. Lee moved the war to northern Virginia, where, in the last days of
August, he trounced Pope's army at the Battle of Second Manassas. Both Bucktail battalions
were active in skirmishing throughout the battle, though they operated separately. In the
withdrawal, Kane and his men served as a rear guard at the famous Stone Bridge over Bull
In the wake of Second Manassas, the fragmented
Federal army was quickly reorganized at Washington by General McClellan. Colonel McNeil
welcomed home the four companies who had been dragged away three months earlier by Kane,
and the reunion was joyous indeed, especially for those Bucktails who did not care for
their bold and controversial lieutenant colonel. Kane was promoted for bravery to
brigadier general and left the regiment for good. His departure seems to have been a
turning point for Bucktail. Despite his courage and zeal, Kane had from the outset been a
divisive force in the regiment he had created. With that influence gone, the men united
behind the popular McNeil.
There was little time for Bucktail to reflect
on the future or dwell on stories of his fragmented past, however. Lee had entered
Maryland, and McClellan started his army off in pursuit. The Federals came up with Lee's
rear guard at South Mountain, about 45 miles northwest of Washington, on September 14. The
Pennsylvania Reserves pushed up the eastern slope of the mountain. Bucktail, less than 300
strong, was in the advance, moving from tree to tree and sheltering behind boulders and
stone walls. The Confederates fired down from their strong positions to good effect,
keeping the Pennsylvanian's at bay until one officer took the issue into his own hands.
Bucktail Captain Edward Irvin, the same man who had stubbornly led his Company K through
the Chickahominy swamps for six days without food, leaped into the open and shouted
"Forward Bucktails, drive them from the position." The men
After a day of rest and light
marching, the Bucktails were again on the skirmish line as afternoon came on September 16.
They crossed a stone bridge over Antietam Creek and moved forward in the advance of their
brigade. Southerners firing from a patch of woods halted the Pennsylvanians in a plowed
field. McNeil at once prepared for a general engagement. He sent word back to the brigade
for support and deployed all his men. Artillery opened on both sides, and the Bucktails
began taking cannon and musket fire. McNeil could wait no longer for the slow supports to
come up. He got his men moving.
There was no cover in the field, so Bucktail
advanced quickly. The Confederate fire increased as the Northerners drew nearer the woods.
The number of Pennsylvanians failing bloody to the furrows grew, and instinctively the
whole regiment lay down. The enemy bullets flew above him and Bucktail fired from the
prone position, sending round after round from Sharps breechloaders into the tree line 75
yards away. He began to creep forward, standing, running a few steps then again hitting
the earth as flashes lit the tree line. Suddenly, Colonel McNeil stood and bellowed,
"Forward, Bucktails, forward." The words were scarcely out before he dropped
again to the earth, a bullet through his chest. Bucktail heeded his final order,
And so Bucktail sat on the morning of September
17 on the edge of a wood north of Sharpsburg. Barely 200 men remained of the nearly 900
that had begun four months earlier, and fighting that day would reduce them by another
three dozen. The summer had left one colonel dead and two lieutenant colonels, a major and
an adjutant wounded. Seven of the 10 captains had been killed, wounded or lost to disease
or enemy prisons - some of them more than once -leaving just two company commanders and
the adjutant to lead the regiment at Antietam.
And there was much more of the same ahead. At
Fredericksburg,
Four hundred and twenty-two Bucktails became casualties in 11 days of
fighting that summer. Some of the fallen returned to the regiment. Most did not. Those who
made it to Sharpsburg and beyond were as cocky as they had ever been, perhaps more, but by
then