26
Weary Race to a Court House
243
After a
night that seemed far too short, the energetic, driving Hancock early sent his men tearing
into Hill's Southern soldiers over on the plank road. A little later in some manner
Wadsworth got his division on the Confederate flank. For a while things looked good
indeed for Federal arms on the Union left. But the situation suddenly changed when the
familiar Rebel yell announced the arrival of Longstreet's First Corps. Burnside was on his
way to bolster the Union Second Corps, but he seemed to be coming along so slowly. On
the Union right, near the turnpike, Sedgwick and Warren were keeping Ewell's Confederates
pinned down without too much difficulty.
For the Reserves, May 6 was to be a
day of considerable chasing here and there. As it turned out, they would not accomplish
very much by this, but it would not be the fault of the men. Shortly after dawn Crawford's
two little brigades, to the left of Griffin and south of the pike, were ready for the
day's work. Skirmishers were advanced, but things were relatively quiet as the fighting
raged off on the left. The morning hours dragged on with an occasional artillery exchange,
punctuated now and then by the sputter of rifle and musket. By noon, with Longstreet's
yelling veterans over on the plank road, it looked like the Union Second Corps would soon
need support. Burnside was not proving
244
very
effective. Meade ordered the Fifth and Sixth Corps commanders to suspend any attack and to
let him know what troops they could spare to help Hancock.[1]
Shortly Warren received two urgent
requests from Meade to send support to the Second Corps. The Reserves were a part of the
force which was sent down through the woods to bolster Hancock's hard fighters. A half
hour after Meade had sent his last plea for help for Hancock things had become better for
the Second Corps. The Army commander sent Warren word to recall the detached troops. So,
having just marched down through the woods, the Reserves marched back again.
The men had hardly had time to settle
back in the old line and eat a little hardtack when the Fifth Corps chief received another
message from G.H.Q. This time there was trouble on the Union right. More yelling Rebels
had gotten around Sedgwick. This important Union flank, so close to the Rapidan and the
supply route, was supposed to have been covered by cavalry. The troopers were green, and
the Confederates had found their way through. The Sixth Corps was having a hard time. So
Crawford hurried his men through the woods again, this time to the north. Old John
Sedgwick was having trouble indeed, as the Rebels came pouring in. However, he had gone to
work skillfully reshuffling his units. By the time the Reserves division got to the scene
of the latest Southern break-through, it had been patched up. The Bucktails stood guard
along one of the innumerable Wilderness cross-trails while the division tried to find
out where it was needed. Finally, Crawford was told he could take the Reserves back to the
Lacy farm. In the gathering darkness the Bucktails stepped into the line now headed back
through the woods once more.[2]
The next morning the Wilderness was
shrouded in fog
245
and smoke.
For two days the two armies had been fighting each other. Now they were about where they
had started the morning Griffin bumped into Ewell. It seemed that neither side was anxious
to do any more fighting in that blinding tangle. However, both sides kept watch for what
the other might do. As a part of this feeling-out-the-enemy process the Bucktails were to
have a rough workout.
General Warren seemed particularly
concerned about what the enemy might do on his front should gray artillery be placed on
some high ground along the little road leading to Parker's Store. By ten o'clock it
appeared to the Fifth Corps commander that Lee was withdrawing, and that there was only a
rear guard left on the corps front. Warren ordered both Griffin and Crawford to push out
very heavy skirmish lines to find out just how true were the reports of the Confederates
falling back.[3]
The Bucktails and the Sixth Reserves
received the nod for this assignment. A little after ten they started out along the lane
toward Parker's Store. On either side the men found themselves in a thick tangle of
stunted pines, scrub oaks, and all sorts of vines and creeping underbrush. How different
to the Pennsylvania woodsmen was this conglomerate of second growth from the tall forests
of virgin timber where they earned their living before the war. The pine which the
lumbermen had cut in the Wildcat District reached up toward the heavens 150 feet and
measured five or six feet through. Underbrush like the men were now crawling through would
never have a chance to grow amid the tall, stalwart trees of the Wildcat District.
Bucktail Companies D, F, G, and K
were deployed at intervals which on decent fighting terrain would have been a double
line of skirmishers. Major Hartshorne put his other six companies in close behind. The
Sixth Regiment was di-
246
vided and
scrambled through the brush on either side of the First Rifles to protect the flanks. The
two regiments inched through the thickets for about half a mile when suddenly they came up
against a strong line of Rebel skirmishers. Almost as if to make up for two days of
comparative inactivity, when units all around them had been fighting their hearts out,
the two Reserves regiments started to drive. Out of the brush into a little open field
they pushed the enemy skirmishers. In the field they were met by another heavy line of
gray soldiers. With their Spencers barking a steady flame, the Bucktails drove the Rebels
back into their rifle pits. On a knoll back of the pits the artillery, which Warren had
been worrying about, had been placed. The guns let out with a burst of grape and canister.
The chase was over. Crawford ordered the two little regiments to fall back. Although it
was stubborn, it was only a small Rebel pocket. That was what topside wanted to know.
For the Bucktails, it was
"mission accomplished," as they trudged back over Wilderness Run and along the
lane. They carried their dead and wounded with them. The action had been short, but
sharp. In the few minutes in the thickets and the little field the First Rifles had
suffered most of their casualties of the Wilderness fighting, two dead, twenty-three
wounded.[4]
Gradually through the day orders for
the next move filtered down through the chains of command from the general-in-chief.
Although the men would not know what the plans were until the Army started out, Grant's
decision had been made for quite a while. He had issued the order at six-thirty that
morning. It called for another of his several moves to the left, moves which would finally
take the Army of the Potomac from the Rapidan across the James. Then it would be on to
Petersburg and eventually to a little court
247
house in
central Virginia, called Appomattox. All that was months ahead. Meanwhile, there would be
much more marching, and fighting, and dying.
The Union Army was going to leave the
Wilderness and fight some place where it could take advantage of its superior numbers. The
Fifth Corps was to leave at eight-thirty that evening, but it was somewhat later when the
column started along the turnpike and turned right onto the Brock Road. That turn south,
instead of back toward the Rapidan, was significant. It was indicative of how U. S. Grant
proposed to fight the war from then on. With the Pennsylvania Reserves well up ahead, the
line started southeast. Some fifteen miles ahead was a small hamlet, Spotsylvania Court
House by name. Lee had had a road hacked through the woods south of the plank road, and as
Warren moved along through the spring night, so did the advance units of the Army of
Northern Virginia, by a somewhat shorter route a few miles away.[5]
On that night march General Warren
became much disgusted with the Union cavalry which was supposed to have the way cleared
for the infantry. The Federal troopers were improving all the time, but the night of May
7-8 was not one of their better moments. Around a cross-road, called Todd's Tavern, the
blue troopers had the road completely blocked and seemed unable to straighten out the
tangle. Much valuable time was lost before, as Warren put it, the cavalry "got out
of our way."[6]
Robinson's
Second Division was in the lead when the Fifth Corps was finally able to push on beyond
Todd's Tavern. By this time another day had dawned. The sight which greeted Robinson
across a little valley, a mile or two northwest of Spotsylvania, was gray-clad soldiers
hastily digging in behind earth and fence rails on the opposite ridge. Lee had won the
race. By the time the Reserves and Warren's
248
other
divisions arrived, Robinson's men had been badly shot up by Longstreet's soldiers.
Crawford's Division went into the
battle on the left of Griffin's First Division. The Bucktails were on the division right
next to Griffin's men. These were the soldiers who had started the Wilderness fighting.
Now Major Hartshorne could see a Rebel line all poised to hit Griffin in the left flank.
The Bucktail commander sent Captain Sam Mack, with a squad of Company E men, through a
little wood to break up this movement. Mack was able to get his men on the flank of the
Southern would-be flankers. The little Bucktail squad went to work with their Spencers.
The Rebels soon started to return the fire. Mack's men were woefully out-numbered. Every
one of them stopped Southern lead. Mack himself picked up two bullets.
In the slow advance across the
shallow valley McCandless was wounded. The ground was uneven and full of ditches, and the
Confederate fire was hot. After McCandless was knocked out of action, the Reserves became
somewhat mixed up. When the rest of the Union line was shoved back, the Pennsylvania
soldiers were glad to fall back too. Just before his division had gone forward, an enemy
shell had cut off the top of a tree near where Crawford was standing. The top fell on the
division commander, and he was out of the fighting for a while.[7]
Colonel S. M. Jackson, of the
Eleventh Reserves, found himself at the head of the First Brigade as another try at the
opposite ridge was decided upon. Nightfall was approaching, but Sedgwick's Corps was up.
The artillery, which had not been able to do much in the Wilderness, had been pounding the
Rebel line. With the First Brigade leading, the Reserves struggled forward once more, as
the two Union corps tried to do something while it was still daylight. The
249
tired-out
soldiers just could not do it.[8]
The battle died down with the Southern Army spread out in a great ragged semicircle
around the little grove of trees where stood Spotsylvania Court House. Around this
ragged arc, the northern Army had spread another uneven half-circle. The Bucktails, along
with all the other little outfits, which had marched and fought so long, fell back to the
line of the Union arc. As the night drew in and the guns stopped their barking, a long
line of loaded ambulances started bumping back toward Fredericksburg. In the darkness
skirmish lines sputtered, and General Phil Sheridan started out on what was hoped would be
a big cavalry raid toward Richmond.
To the south of the Union line ran
the Po River. The next morning the First Brigade of the Reserves was sent out on a
reconnaissance in that direction. The Bucktails had their usual position as skirmishers.
They were joined by the First Regiment and a squad of the famed Berdan Sharpshooters.
Back in the Peninsula days the First Rifles, then armed with muzzle-loaders, had fought
side by side with the Sharps-armed Berdan men. On that occasion the Bucktails' envy of the
Sharpshooters, because of their breech-loaders, was greener than the uniforms which the
Berdan men wore. This time it would be different.
When the
river was reached, and while the brigade brass were trying to determine what next to do,
the Berdan squad and a platoon of Bucktails started a little shooting match. Their target
was a nest of butternut-clad soldiers across the river who had been sending some rather
saucy bullets over the stream. The Sharpshooters started firing first. Soon the
Spencer-armed Bucktails decided that the Berdan fire was much too slow. From this point
on, like some other stories of Bucktail marksmanship, the story becomes a bit difficult to
believe. Not only was the fire of the First Rifles platoon
250
much faster
than that of the Sharpshooters; it was more accurate than that of this crack outfit.
While the Berdan score was zero, the Bucktail platoon dropped two Rebels and flushed the
rest out of the bushes. The range was one thousand yards. The regimental historians
recorded it all very solemnly.[9]
[1] O. R., 36 (2), pp. 455-456, Warren to
Griffin; p. 449, Warren to Humphreys, Humphreys to Warren; pp. 451-452, Humphreys to
Warren, Meade to Warren.
[2] Sypher, pp. 516-517; O. R., 36 (2), p.
454, Humphreys to Warren (three messages); p. 438, Meade to Grant.
[3] O.. R., 36 (2), p. 499, Warren to
Humphreys; p. 504, Warren to Crawford.
[4] Woodward, p. 306; T. & R., p. 297;
O. R., 36 (2), pp. 504-505. Crawford to Warren (two messages). This little skirmish
accounted for most of the Bucktail casualties in the Wilderness fighting. O. R., 36 (1),
p. 124, Return of Casualties, May 5-7, shows the following for the First Rifles: killed
three; wounded thirty-one; missing three.
[5] O. R., 36 (2), p. 481, Grant to Meade;
p. 484, Meade's Order; Sypher, p. 520.
[6] O. R., 36 (1), p. 540-541, Warren's
Journal. For the Spotsylvania Court House fighting, see Catton, A Stillness at Appomattox,
pp. 90146; Freeman, R. E. Lee, Vol. 3 Chs. 18-19, Lee's Lieutenants, Vol. 3, Chs. 19-22.
[7] . O. R., 36 (2), pp. 539-540, Warren
to Humphreys; T. & R., pp. 300-301; Woodward, pp. 311-312.
[8] . Sypher, pp. 522-524. Neither
Crawford, McCandless, nor any of the commanders of the Reserves regiments filed reports of
the Wilderness-Spotsylvania fighting. This has added to the difficulty of tracing the
division during this period.